Market Saturation and Utilization Data Tool
Market Saturation and Utilization Data Tool
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) has developed a Market Saturation and Utilization Data Tool that includes interactive maps and a dataset that shows national-, state-, and county-level provider services and utilization data for selected health service areas. Market saturation, in the present context, refers to the density of providers of a particular service within a defined geographic area relative to the number of the beneficiaries receiving that service in the area.
The eighth release of the data tool includes a quarterly update of the data to the sixteen health services areas from release 7, and also includes Preventive Health Services data. Release 8 also includes two additional reference periods, and will therefore include nine, twelve-month reference periods and the following health service areas: Home Health, Ambulance (Emergency, Non-Emergency, Emergency & Non-Emergency), Independent Diagnostic Testing Facilities (Part A and Part B), Skilled Nursing Facilities, Hospice, Physical and Occupational Therapy, Clinical Laboratory (Billing Independently), Long-Term Care Hospitals, Chiropractic Services, Cardiac Rehabilitation Programs, Psychotherapy, Federally Qualified Health Centers, Ophthalmology, and Preventive Health Services. Also new to Release 8 are three new metrics for dual eligibility including Number of Dual Eligible Users, Percentage of Dual Eligible Users out of Total Users and Percentage of Dual Eligible Users out of Dual Eligible FFS Beneficiaries and an addition to the interactive trend graph. The interactive trend graph allows users to graph trends over time for selected geographies at the national and state-level by selecting a metric and health service area from the dropdown menu.
The Market Saturation and Utilization Data Tool is one of many tools used by CMS to monitor and manage market saturation as a means to help prevent potential fraud, waste, and abuse. The data can also be used to reveal the degree to which use of a service is related to the number of providers servicing a geographic region. Provider services and utilization data by geographic regions are easily compared using an interactive map. There are a number of secondary research uses for these data, but one objective of making these data public is to assist health care providers in making informed decisions about their service locations and the beneficiary population they serve. The tool is available through the CMS website at: https://data.cms.gov/market-saturation. Future releases may include comparable information on additional health service areas.
The analysis is based on paid Medicare Fee-for-Service (FFS) claims data from the CMS Integrated Data Repository (IDR). The IDR contains Medicare FFS claims, beneficiary data, provider data, and plan data. FFS claims data are analyzed for a 12-month reference period, and results are updated quarterly to reflect a more recent 12-month reference period.
The Market Saturation and Utilization methodology is different from other public use data with respect to determining the geographic location of a provider. In this analysis, claims are used to define the geographic area(s) served by a provider rather than the provider’s practice address. Further, a provider is defined as “serving a county” if, during the 12-month reference period, the provider had paid claims for more than ten beneficiaries located in a county. A provider is defined as “serving a state” if that provider serves any county in the state.
The Market Saturation and Utilization methodology is also different from other public use data with respect to determining the number of Medicare beneficiaries who are enrolled in a fee-for-service (FFS) program. In this analysis, a FFS beneficiary is defined as being enrolled in Part A and/or Part B with a coverage type code equal to “9” (FFS coverage) for at least one month of the 12-month reference period. There must not be a death date for that month or a missing zip code for the beneficiary so that the beneficiary can be assigned to a county. Other public use data may define a FFS beneficiary using different criteria, such as requiring the beneficiary to be enrolled in the FFS program every month during the reference period.
Starting with Release 7 (April 2018), the interactive data set for all reference periods includes state- and county-level data for the following United States territories, commonwealths, and freely associated states: American Samoa (AS); Micronesia (FM); Guam (GU); Northern Mariana Islands (MP); Puerto Rico (PR); and the U.S. Virgin Islands (VI). The national-level data in the interactive data set for all previous reference periods reflects the U.S. plus the aforementioned territories.
The Market Saturation and Utilization Tool does not include information on market saturation and utilization for Medicaid or private insurance. Dual eligible metrics are produced from Medicare claims data only and therefore do not incorporate Medicaid claims data.
The Market Saturation and Utilization Data Tool includes an interactive map that is color-coded based on an analysis that separates the distribution into the following categories of states/counties for the selected metric: lowest 25 percent, second lowest 25 percent, third lowest 25 percent, top 25 percent excluding extreme values, and extreme values. An extreme value is one that greatly differs from other values in its field (e.g., Number of Providers). Counties that are excluded from the analysis are colored gray in the interactive map.
For those interested in states and counties affected by CMS’ temporary provider enrollment moratoria during the reference periods for which data are available, the interactive map permits a visualization that identifies those states and counties. In this visualization, Ambulance and Home Health service areas for moratoria versus non-moratoria states/counties are identified based on color scheme.
The examples below utilize the Ambulance (Emergency & Non-Emergency) service area data (selected for illustration purposes only). Similar maps can be created through the Data Tool for all of the health service areas included in the eighth release and for the nine, twelve-month reference periods:
- October 1, 2014 through September 30, 2015
- January 1, 2015 through December 31, 2015
- April 1, 2015 through March 31, 2016
- July 1, 2015 through June 30, 2016
- October 1, 2015 through September 30, 2016
- January 1, 2016 through December 31, 2016
- April 1, 2016 through March 31, 2017
- July 1, 2016 through June 30, 2017
- October 1, 2016 through September 30, 2017
Map 1 displays the distribution of providers by state for the October 1, 2016 through September 30, 2017 reference period. The dual color scale distinguishes between moratoria (blue) and non-moratoria states (green).
Map 1. Home Health:
National Distribution of Number of Providers
October 1, 2016 – September 30, 2017
Color by Moratoria Status
Similar maps can be created at the national- and state-level for the other metrics included in the Data Tool: Number of FFS Beneficiaries, Average Number of Users per Provider, Percentage of Users out of FFS Beneficiaries, Number of Users, Average Number of Providers per County, Number of Dual Eligible Users, Percentage of Dual Eligible Users out of Total Users, Percentage of Dual Eligible Users out of Dual Eligible FFS Beneficiaries, and Total Payments.
Navigating the Interactive Trend Graph
Begin by selecting a Metric and Health Service Area from the dropdown. Next, click on the State of interest. A trend line graph of the selected metric will be displayed for the available reference periods. Additional States and Nation + Territories can be added and viewed together on a single graph by selecting the state(s) or Nation + Territories using the dropdown menu above the graph. Data values for the selected additional states and Nation + Territories are displayed by scrolling over the trend lines.