List of PRRB Decisions

List of PRRB Decisions

The Provider Reimbursement Review Board is an independent panel to which a certified Medicare provider of services may appeal if it is dissatisfied with a final determination by its Medicare contractor or by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS).  A decision of the Board may be affirmed, modified, reversed, or vacated and remanded by the CMS Admistrator within 60 days of notification to the provider of that decision.

 

Decision # Case # Provider # Issue
2024D28
15-2868
14-0150
Whether the Medicare Contractor ("Medicare Contractor") determined the Medicare reimbursement of the operating and capital outliers, and the corresponding time value of money ("TVM"), through the outlier reconciliation process properly. This issue relate...
2024D27
19-1917
18-4012
Whether the Elizabethtown Core Based Statistical Area ("CBSA") 21060 Wage Index was correctly established for Medicare payments made to the Provider during its fiscal year ending April 30, 2017.
2024D26
21-0412
05-0254
Whether the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") properly determined that the federal fiscal year ("FFY") 2021 payment update to the inpatient prospective payment system ("IPPS") for the hospital should be reduced by one fourth because the hos...
2024D25
17-1027
17-1358
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly disallowed the allocated related party costs claimed by Lindsborg Community Hospital ("Provider" or "Lindsborg") for fiscal year ("FY") 2015.
2024D24
21-0266GC
49-4010; 49-4021
Whether the Medicare Contractor's decision to disallow all professional costs for the Providers' fiscal years ("FYs") 2016 and 2017 was proper, given the Providers are teaching hospitals.
2024D23
16-2591
15-0011
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Marion General Hospital ("Marion General" of the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period...
2024D22
22-0953
15-3045
Whether the Community Stroke and Rehabilitation Center ("Community Stroke" or "Provider") should be subject to a two (2) percentage point reduction to its federal fiscal year 2022 inpatient rehabilitation facility annual payment update ("APU") for failure...
2024D21
19-0263
24-0166
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Mayo Clinic Health System - Fairmont ("Mayo Clinic Fairmont" or "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost r...
2024D20
18-0120
18-0038
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Owensboro Health Regional Hospital ("Owensboro Health" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred during its fisc...
2024D19
17-1846
49-0069
1. Whether the Provider is entitled to receive reimbursement for its Medicare Managed Care ("Medicare Part C") costs incurred through its nursing and allied health ("NAH") program, based on the requirements in 42 C.F.R. § 413.87, when the Provider submit...
2024D18
19-2081, 21-1783
36-0041
Did the Medicare Contractor properly determine the Provider's Per Resident Amount ("PRA") for fiscal year ending December 31, 2016 ("FY 2016")?
2024D17
14-2534
43-0012
Whether the Medicare Contractor appropriately made adjustments, which eliminated pass-through reimbursement of Avera Sacred Heart Hospital's ("Avera" or "the Provider") Nursing Education costs for fiscal year ("FY") 2010, pursuant to 42 C.F.R. § 413.85(g...
2024D16
21-1676
45-2061
Whether the payment penalty that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") imposed under the Long-Term Care Hospital Quality Reporting Program ("LTCH QRP") to reduce the Provider's payment update for Fiscal Year ("FY") 2017 by two percentage po...
2024D15
19-0124
05-0435
Whether Fallbrook District Hospital (the "Provider") is entitled to a volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending June 30, 2015 ("FY 2015").
2024D14
17-1313
05-0435
Whether Fallbrook District Hospital (the "Provider") is entitled to a volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending June 30, 2014 ("FY 2014").
2024D13
17-1243
33-0250
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Champlain Valley Physicians Hospital ("Champlain Valley" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred during its fi...
2024D12
17-1252
33-0250
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Champlain Valley Physicians Hospital ("Champlain Valley" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred during its fi...
2024D11
17-1312
39-0084
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor, Wisconsin Physicians Service ("WPS"), properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment owed to Sunbury Community Hospital ("Sunbury" or "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that...
2024D10
18-0547
33-0276
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Nathan Littauer Hospital ("Nathan Littauer" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred during its cost reporting ...
2024D09
17-0004
33-0276
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Nathan Littauer Hospital ("Nathan Littauer" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred during its cost reporting ...
2024D08
16-2145
33-0276
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Nathan Littauer Hospital ("Nathan Littauer" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred during its cost reporting ...
2024D07
18-1014
23-0130
This case involves the following three issues for the fiscal year ending December 31, 2013 ("FY 2013"): 1. Whether the Medicare Contractor should have adjusted William Beaumont Hospital - Royal Oak's (hereinafter "Provider" or "Beaumont") nursing school ...
2024D06
17-2113
34-0106
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Sandhills Regional Medical Center ("Sandhills" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting p...
2024D05
21-0760
14-1694
Whether the Medicare Contractor used the correct time-period and calculations for determining the Provider's hospice cap amount for the cap year ending on September 30, 2019.
2024D04
21-0661
16-1544
Whether the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") properly imposed a two percentage point reduction to the fiscal year ("FY") 2021 Medicare annual payment update ("APU") for Hospice of Washington County (the "Provider").
2024D03
20-1792
03-0111
Whether the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") properly imposed a two percentage point reduction to the Provider's Federal Fiscal Year ("FFY") 2020 Annual Payment Update ("APU") under the Inpatient Psychiatric Facility Quality Reporting ("IP...
2024D02
14-0786GC
32-0002; 45-0046; 45-0034
Whether the disproportionate share hospital ("DSH") payments for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2009 ("FY 2009") of each of the Christus Health Providers should be revised to include additional Medicaid labor and delivery room ("LDR") patient days that w...
2024D01
14-2200
39-0197
Whether the Medicare Contractor's determination of the Provider's disproportionate share hospital ("DSH") payment for fiscal year ("FY") 2010 should be revised to include additional Medicaid patient days that were excluded from the numerator of the Medica...
2023D36
13-0583GC, 13-1710GC, 14-0584GC, 14-3382GC, 14-3963GC & 15-1816GC
Various
Whether the Medicare Contractor's disallowance of Medicare Bad Debts claimed by the Providers for the fiscal years at issue, on the grounds that they had not been returned from a collection agency, was proper.
2023D35
20-0218
10-2026
Whether the payment penalty that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") imposed under the Long-Term Care Hospital Quality Reporting Program ("LTCH-QRP") which reduced the Provider's payment update for Federal Fiscal Year ("FFY") 2020 by two ...
2023D34
21-0114
45-0876
Whether, in connection with the hospital Inpatient Quality Reporting ("IQR") program, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services' ("CMS") decision to reduce the Annual Percentage Update ("APU") to the Federal Fiscal Year ("FFY") 2021 Inpatient Prospecti...
2023D33
14-1468
01-0055
Whether the Medicare Contractor improperly calculated the Provider's Disproportionate Share Hospital ("DSH") reimbursement due to sampling errors in review of the Medicaid-eligible patient days.
2023D32
15-2971, 15-3228, 16-2290 & 17-0907
49-0069
Whether the Provider is entitled to receive reimbursement for its Medicare Part C Managed Care costs incurred through its nursing and allied health ("NAH") program, based on the requirements in 42 C.F.R. § 413.87, when the Provider submitted no-pay bills...
2023D31
14-1112
26-0141
Whether the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") correctly refused to exclude the Missouri Psychiatric Center unit ("MUPC") of the University of Missouri Health Care's ("UMHC" or "Provider") from the inpatient prospective payment system ("IPPS...
2023D30
14-3959, 15-3440, 16-1866, 18-1647, 19-0371 & 22-0536
33-0153
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly determined the Provider's unweighted direct graduate medical education ("GME") and indirect medical education ("IME") full time equivalent ("FTE") resident caps for the fiscal years ("FYs") 2010 and 2012-2016.
2023D29
15-0359, 15-0909 & 16-1527
22-0110
Whether Brigham and Women's Hospital ("Brigham and Women's" or "Provider") timely claimed the $316,565 at issue in the initial fiscal year ("FY") 1989 cost report and, if timely claimed, whether those expenses included Ultrasound and Nuclear Medicine Clin...
2023D28
19-0405
31-0058
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly excluded a lump sum payment of $4,991,315 from the interim payments included on the Provider's notice of program reimbursement ("NPR") for fiscal year ("FY") 2014 and, if so, whether the Provider is entitled to hav...
2023D27
15-2265 & 16-0058
19-0046
Whether the Medicare Contractor's adjustments to remove Full Time Equivalents ("FTEs") from the Graduate Medical Education ("GME") Cap for fiscal years ("FYs") 2010 and 2011 are proper.
2023D26
20-0230
45-0072
Whether the Provider complied with the Affordable Care Act ("ACA") Inpatient Rehabilitation Facility ("IRF") Quality Reporting Program ("QRP") requirements for submission of quality data for the period at issue and, therefore, is not subject to a 2 percen...
2023D25
21-0416
29-2008
Whether the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") properly imposed the penalty, under the Long Term Care Hospital Quality Reporting Program ("LTCH QRP"), to reduce the Provider's Federal fiscal year 2021 ("FFY 2021") Medicare annual payment upd...
2023D24
15-3002
05-0057
Whether the Provider is entitled to reasonable cost reimbursement for its graduate medical education ("GME") start-up costs for the fiscal year ending ("FYE") June 30, 2013.
2023D23
15-3264
04-0016
Whether the Provider's disproportionate share hospital ("DSH") payment for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2012 ("FY 2012") should be revised to include additional Medicaid patient days that were excluded from the numerator of the Medicaid faction.
2023D22
15-2944
04-0016
Whether the Provider's disproportionate share hospital ("DSH") payment for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2011 ("FY 2011") should be revised to include additional Medicaid patient days that were excluded from the numerator of the Medicaid fraction.
2023D21
20-1381
36-1702
Whether the imposition of a two percentage point reduction to the fiscal year ("FY") 2020 Medicare annual percentage update ("APU") for Comfortbrook Hospice d/b/a Grace Hospital ("Grace Hospice" or "Provider") (Provider No. 36-1702) was proper.
2023D20
20-1380
36-1703
Whether the imposition of a two percentage point reduction to the fiscal year ("FY") 2020 Medicare annual percentage update ("APU") for Comfortbrook Hospice d/b/a Grace Hospice (Provider No. 36-1703) ("Grace Hospice" or "Provider") was proper.
2023D19
16-1961
38-0027
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated and denied the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Mercy Medical Center ("Mercy" or "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred for its cost report period ending...
2023D18
16-0304, 16-1222 & 16-1429
50-1330
Whether the Provider is entitled to certain emergency room availability costs including costs for mid-level providers ("MLPs") for the fiscal years ending December 31, 2011, December 31, 2012 and December 31, 2013 ("FYs 2011, 2012, and 2013").
2023D17
15-1665, 16-2122, 18-1200, 19-0260 & 20-0452
10-0080
Whether the Medicare Contractor correctly determined the Graduate Medical Education ("GME") and Indirect Medical Education ("IME") full-time equivalent ("FTE") resident caps for the new Internal Medicine residents training program at JFK Medical Center ("...
2023D16
15-1092
32-0014
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly determined the sole community hospital ("SCH") volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") granted for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2010 ("FY 2010").
2023D15
14-0443
10-0118
Whether the Medicare Contractor's determination to classify the Provider as a Medicare-dependent hospital ("MDH") effective June 6, 2013, as opposed to October 1, 2012, was proper.
2023D14
17-2189
06-0023
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated and denied the the Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") owed to St. Mary's Hospital & Medical Center (" St. Mary's" or "Provider") as a sole community hospital ("SCH") for its cost reporting period ending ...
2023D13
17-1542
53-0014
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the sole community hospital ("SCH") volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Cheyenne Regional Medical Center ("Cheyenne" or "Provider") for its cost reporting period ending June 30, 2014 ("FY 2014").
2023D12
20-1306
25-2006
Whether the payment penalty that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") imposed under the Long Term Care Hospital Quality Reporting Program ("LTCH-QRP") to reduce the Provider's payment update for Federal Fiscal Year ("FFY") 2020 by two perc...
2023D11
17-0927
47-0012
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly reopened the Original Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") approval and whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the Revised VDA owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges t...
2023D10
21-0061
27-0017
Whether the Provider has proven that it is entitled to a Sole Community Hospital Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") for the fiscal year ending December 31, 2015 ("FY 2015").
2023D09
17-1611
14-0040
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Galesburg Cottage Hospital ("Galesburg" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period e...
2023D08
06-1843, 07-1701, 08-1543, 10-0786, 10-1178, 11-0530
15-1301
Was the Medicare Contractor's disallowance of the interest expense proper for St. Vincent Randolph Hospital ("St. Vincent Randolph" or "Provider") for the fiscal years ("FYs") 2004 through 2009?
2023D07
17-0072
23-0095
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment owed to West Branch Regional Medical Center ("West Branch" or "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period en...
2023D06
15-3152
23-0095
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment owed to West Branch Regional Medical Center ("West Branch" or "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period e...
2023D05
15-3079GC
Various
Whether to include Medicaid days of children and adolescents for the hospital's inpatient behavioral health departments in the Medicaid fraction of the Medicare disproportionate share hospital ("DSH") calculation for fiscal year ("FY") 2007 for each of th...
2023D04
17-0931
20-0031
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Cary Medical Center ("Cary" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending Decemb...
2023D03
17-0930
20-0031
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Cary Medical Center ("Cary" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending Decemb...
2023D02
20-0420
14-0040
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Galesburg Cottage Hospital ("Galesburg" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period e...
2023D01
18-1206
14-0040
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Galesburg Cottage Hospital ("Galesburg" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period e...
2022D40
17-1544
49-0037
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated and denied the Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") owed to Riverside Shore Memorial Hospital ("Riverside" or "Provider") for its cost reporting period ending December 31, 2013 ("FY 2013").
2022D39
17-1541
49-0037
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated and denied the Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") owed to Riverside Shore Memorial Hospital ("Riverside" or "Provider") for its cost reporting period ending December 31, 2010 ("FY 2010").
2022D38
15-3066
37-0089
Whether the Provider has proven that it is entitled to the Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") that it seeks for fiscal year ("FY") 2011.
2022D37
14-0643
32-0006
Whether the Provider is entitled to a volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") payment for a sole community hospital ("SCH").
2022D36
17-0182
45-0165
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Methodist Hospital South, formerly known as South Texas Regional Medical Center, ("Methodist Hospital" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in in...
2022D35
14-4410G
34-0091, 50-0044
Whether the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") was arbitrary and capricious in establishing a 10 percent threshold in 2003 and whether CMS was arbitrary and capricious in using the same 10 percent threshold in 2006 to determine whether the P...
2022D34
18-0890, 18-0896, 18-0897, 18-0898, 20-0275G, 20-0621G
Various
Whether it is appropriate to offset the tuition revenue for Nursing and Allied Health ("NAH") programs on Worksheet A-8 or whether it is appropriate to offset the tuition revenue only after the stepdown process.
2022D33
17-0526
14-0040
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Galesburg Cottage Hospital ("Galesburg" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period e...
2022D32
14-1466
14-0040
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Galesburg Cottage Hospital ("Galesburg" or the "Provider") for the greater than five percent decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost repo...
2022D31
16-0187GC, 16-1462GC
Various
Whether the sequestration amount reported on the Provider Statistical and Reimbursement ("PS&R") report for each hospice should be added to the net reimbursement amount in the Aggregate Cap Limitation Calculation to determine payments in excess of the hos...
2022D30
16-2233
15-0030
Whether the Provider is entitled to receive a volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") for a Medicare dependent hospital ("MDH").
2022D29
14-2968
37-0037
Should Medicaid days attributed to child and adolescent patients who received services in three of the Provider's inpatient behavioral health units licensed as psychiatric residential treatment facilities ("PRTFs"), namely ACCENTS (Unit 1929), Human Resto...
2022D28
16-2292
05-0625
Whether the reasonable compensation equivalent ("RCE") limits should have been applied at all to pre-transplant time spent by physicians working for the Provider on organ acquisition-related activities and, if the RCE does apply, whether the Medicare Cont...
2022D27
16-1817
05-0448
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly determined the sole community hospital ("SCH") volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") granted for the short fiscal year ending August 7, 2012 ("Short Period 2012").
2022D26
16-0008
05-0448
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly determined the sole community hospital ("SCH") volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") granted for the fiscal year ending January 31, 2012 ("FY 2012").
2022D25
15-2439
36-0123
Whether the Medicare Contractor erred in disallowing Medicare managed care payments associated with the Provider's operation of its pastoral care allied health education program.
2022D24
14-4177
31-0039
Whether the Medicare Contractor's determination of the Provider's disproportionate share hospital ("DSH") payment [was accurate] and whether that calculation should be revised to include additional Medicaid patient days that were excluded from the numerat...
2022D23
20-0468
19-2022
Whether the payment penalty that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") imposed under the Long Term Care Hospital Quality Reporting Program ("LTCH-QRP") to reduce the Provider's payment update for federal fiscal year ("FFY") 2020 by two perc...
2022D22
15-3430
15-0030
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Henry County Memorial Hospital ("Henry County" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting p...
2022D21
17-1626
32-0063
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Carlsbad Regional Medical Center ("Carlsbad" or "Provider") for its cost reporting period ending August 31, 2014 ("FY 2014").
2022D20
17-0981
33-0085
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the Revised Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending December 31, 2012 ("FY 2012"), a...
2022D19
15-3335
16-0032
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Skiff Medical Center ("Skiff" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending June...
2022D18
15-1708, 15-1709, 15-1688
20-0041, 20-0050, 20-0037
Whether the Medicare Contractor's adjustment for fiscal year ("FY") 2012, which reduced the Providers' allowable Medicare reasonable costs by offsetting a portion of the Providers' Medicaid payments against the Providers' Maine Hospital Tax expense, was p...
2022D17
15-3405
39-1544
Whether the Medicare Contractor used the correct data and methodology in calculating and applying a hospice cap on Tender Loving Care for the 2013 Cap Year.
2022D16
17-0848
33-0177
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the Revised Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending December 31, 2011 ("FY 2011"), a...
2022D15
12-0630
16-0032
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Skiff Medical Center ("Skiff" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending June...
2022D14
11-0501
16-0032
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Skiff Medical Center ("Skiff" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending June...
2022D13
17-0933
33-0033
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Chenango Memorial Hospital ("Chenango" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period en...
2022D12
14-0032
36-0079
Did the Medicare Contractor err when it made an adjustment for fiscal year ("FY") 2009 to remove the Provider's protested item for the addition of Allied Health Program revenue to the accumulated cost allocation statistic, Audit Adjustment No. 26?
2022D11
14-2776
23-0095
Whether the West Branch Regional Medical Center ("West Branch" or "Provider") is entitled to a volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") payment for a sole community hospital ("SCH") for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2010 ("FY 2010").
2022D10
13-3788
23-0095
Whether the West Branch Regional Medical Center ("West Branch" or "Provider") is entitled to a volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") payment for a sole community hospital ("SCH") for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2009 ("FY 2009").
2022D09
17-0272
45-0489
Whether Medical Arts Hospital ("Medical Arts" or the "Provider") is entitled to a volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") for the fiscal year ending March 31, 2012 ("FY 2012").
2022D08
18-1559, 19-2776
23-0055
Whether the Medicare Contractor erred in its determination that the Provider did not qualify for the exception to the per-visit upper payment limit ("UPL") for rural health clinics ("RHCs") for fiscal years ending December 31, 2015 and December 31, 2016 (...
2022D07
20-1892
34-0040
Whether the Provider's disproportionate share hospital ("DSH") payment for fiscal year ending September 30, 2009 ("FY 2009") should be revised to include additional patient days that were excluded from the numerator of the Medicaid fraction.
2022D06
17-1612
37-0030
Whether the Provider is entitled to a Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") for Fiscal Year End ("FYE") 03/31/2012.
2022D05
17-1631
14-0294
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Crossroads Community Hospital ("Crossroads" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting peri...
2022D04
16-1924
14-0184
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Marion Memorial Hospital ("Marion" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending...
2022D03
19-1449
22-2007
Whether the payment penalty that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") imposed under the Long Term Care Hospital Quality Reporting Program ("LTCH-QRP") which reduced the Provider's payment update for Fiscal Year ("FY") 2019 by two percent w...
2022D02
17-0274
45-0073
Whether D.M. Cogdell Memorial Hospital ("Cogdell" or the "Provider") is entitled to a Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") from the Medicare Contractor for the fiscal year ending December 31, 2010 ("FY 2010").
2022D01
17-0788
45-0073
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment owed to D.M. Cogdell Memorial Hospital ("Cogdell" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending ...
2021D44
18-0031
45-0370
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Columbus Community Hospital ("Columbus" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period e...
2021D43
17-0592
27-0003
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment owed to St. Peter's Hospital ("St. Peter's" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending May 31...
2021D42
14-0406
37-0059
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor, Novitas Solutions, Inc. ("Medicare Contractor"), properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Stillwater Medical Center ("Stillwater" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in ...
2021D41
17-0980
33-0223
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the Revised Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending December 31, 2013 ("FY 2013"), a...
2021D40
17-0979
33-0223
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the Revised Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending December 31, 2012 ("FY 2012"), a...
2021D39
17-0978
33-0223
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the Revised Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending December 31, 2009 ("FY 2009"), a...
2021D38
15-3450
45-0615
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Atlanta Memorial Hospital ("Atlanta Memorial" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting pe...
2021D37
15-3448
45-0615
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Atlanta Memorial Hospital ("Atlanta Memorial" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting pe...
2021D36
15-3436
45-0615
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Atlanta Memorial Hospital ("Atlanta Memorial" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting pe...
2021D35
17-0648
26-0186
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment owed to Lake Regional Health System ("Lake" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending April ...
2021D34
16-1950
26-0186
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjusted owed to Lake Regional Health System ("Lake" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending April 30...
2021D33
18-1799
28-0077
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Fremont Area Medical Center ("Fremont" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period en...
2021D32
16-2144
28-0077
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Fremont Area Medical Center ("Fremont" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period en...
2021D31
14-1615
28-0077
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Fremont Area Medical Center ("Fremont" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period en...
2021D30
18-0250
45-0653
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") payment for Scenic Mountain Medical Center for the cost reporting period ending December 31, 2014 ("FY 2014").
2021D29
17-1311
45-0653
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") payment for Scenic Mountain Medical Center for the cost reporting period ending December 31, 2013 ("FY 2013").
2021D28
16-1919
45-0653
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") payment for Scenic Mountain Medical Center for the cost reporting period ending December 31, 2012 ("FY 2012").
2021D27
19-1472
34-5522
Whether the payment penalty imposed by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") to reduce Universal Health Care's ("Provider" or "Universal") Fiscal Year ("FY") 2019 Medicare payment by two percent was proper.
2021D26
17-0849
33-0218
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the Revised Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending December 31, 2011 ("FY 2011"), a...
2021D25
17-1021
33-0263
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the Revised Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending December 31, 2012 ("FY 2012"), a...
2021D24
17-1016
33-0263
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the Revised Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending December 31, 2011 ("FY 2011"), a...
2021D23
16-2143GC
Various
Whether the Medicare Contractor's inclusion of sequestered payments in the determination of the Providers' cap on overall Medicare reimbursement was proper.
2021D22
19-2078
14-1694
Whether the Medicare Contractor used the correct number of Medicare beneficiaries in calculating the Cap Year 2018 Hospice Cap.
2021D21
17-0850
33-0215
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the Revised Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending December 31, 2011 ("FY 2011"), a...
2021D20
15-1617
32-0003
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending August 31, 2010 ("FY 2010").
2021D19
14-0442
32-0003
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending August 31, 2008 ("FY 2008").
2021D18
17-2259
45-0055
Whether Rolling Plains Memorial Hospital ("Rolling Plains" or "Provider") is entitled to a Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") for Fiscal Year End September 30, 2012 ("FY 2021"), greater than the amount determined by the Medicare Contractor.
2021D17
17-1984
45-0055
Whether Rolling Plains Memorial Hospital ("Rolling Plains" or "Provider") is entitled to a Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") for Fiscal Year End September 30, 2010.
2021D16
19-1988
22-7515
Whether the payment penalty imposed on the Provider's home health prospective payment system Annual Payment Update ("APU") for calendar year ("CY") 2019 was proper.
2021D15
17-1947
45-0698
Whether the Provider is entitled to a Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") for Fiscal Year End September 30, 2012 ("FY 2012") greater than the amount determined by the Medicare Contractor.
2021D14
18-1545, 18-1669, 18-1802
18-0029
1. For Case No. 18-1454, whether CMS' decision to reduce the Provider's Fiscal Year ("FY") 2018 Inpatient Psychiatric Facility Prospective Payment System annual payment update ("APU") by 2 percentage points proper? 2. For Case No. 18-1669, whether CMS' d...
2021D13
19-0070
92-1588
Whether the two-percentage point reduction to the Annual Percentage Update ("APU") of ProHealth Home Care, Inc. ("ProHealth" or "Provider") for Fiscal Year ("FY") 2019 was proper.
2021D12
20-0536
45-0587
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending September 30, 2016 ("FY 2016").
2021D11
19-2624
45-0587
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending September 30, 2015 ("FY 2015").
2021D10
18-1202
45-0587
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending September 30, 2014 ("FY 2014").
2021D09
17-1625
45-0587
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending September 30, 2013 ("FY 2013").
2021D08
16-1508
45-0587
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending September 30, 2012 ("FY 2012").
2021D07
12-0564
45-0587
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending September 30, 2007 ("FY 2007").
2021D06
19-0114
39-0072
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to the Provider for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending June 30, 2015 ("FY 2015").
2021D05
17-2258
45-0565
Whether Palo Pinto General Hospital ("Palo Pinto" or "Provider") is entitled to a Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") for the Fiscal Year Ended September 30, 2012 ("FY 2012"), greater than the amount determined by the Medicare Contractor.
2021D04
16-0927, 16-1860, 16-2470
16-1356
Whether the Medicare Contractor improperly disallowed certain related party costs claimed by Henry County Health Center ("Henry Center" or "Provider") based on its determination that Henry Center had not incurred the claimed costs.
2021D03
17-1316
39-0072
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Berwick Hospital Center ("Berwick" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending...
2021D02
17-0003
39-0072
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") owed to Berwick Hospital Center ("Berwick" or the "Provider") for the significant decrease in inpatient discharges that occurred in its cost reporting period ending...
2021D01
16-2000GC, 16-2002
11-1719, 11-1728
Whether the Medicare Contractor used the correct data and methodology in calculating and applying the "hospice cap" for Cap Years 2013 (Provider No. 11-1719) and 2014 (Provider Nos. 11-1719 and 11-1728).
2020D25
16-2381
16-1362
Whether the Medicare Contractor improperly disallowed certain related party costs claimed by Cherokee Regional Medical Center ("Cherokee" or "Provider") based on its determination that Cherokee Regional Medical Center had not incurred the claimed costs.
2020D24
13-0394
19-2037
Whether the Medicare Contractor's adjustment to the outlier reconciliation adjustment determination was proper.
2020D23
16-1155
38-0002
Whether the contractor was correct in calculating the Provider's Sole Community Hospital Volume Decrease Adjustment.
2020D22
18-0556
42-0027
Whether the denial of the Provider's request for sole community hospital ("SCH") designation by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") and the Medicare Contractor was proper.
2020D21
18-1331
03-7450
Whether the Medicare Contractor's reduction to the Provider's home health prospective payment system (" HHA PPS") payments for calendar year ("CY") 2018 by two percent was proper.
2020D20
08-2236GC, 09-1414GC, 10-1019GC, 11-0106GC
Various
Whether the Providers' Medicare bad debts pending at outside collection agencies are allowable.
2020D19
10-0520, 12-0427
14-0276
Whether the Medicare Contractor should adjust the direct graduate medical education ("GME") cap for Loyola University Medical Center ("Loyola" or "Provider") on Worksheet E-3, Part VI of the Provider's cost reports for fiscal years ("FYs") 2006 and 2007, ...
2020D18
16-1507
26-1595
Whether the Medicare Contractor's amended hospice cap calculation properly calculated the Provider's hospice aggregate cap overpayment when it included in "the amount of payment made" certain funds that were sequestered and never paid to the Provider.
2020D17
16-0408GC, 16-0409GC, 16-2238GC
Various
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor improperly denied Medicare reimbursement for the Providers' Medicare bad debt for indigent patients.
2020D16
15-2435, 15-2436, 15-2437
36-0037
Issue 1 - Whether the Medicare Contractor's adjustments for disallowing pass-through costs and managed care payments associated with the Provider's operation of its pastoral care allied health education program were proper. Issue 2 - Whether the Medicare...
2020D15
12-0269
35-0070
Whether the Medicare Contractor's adjustment to reconcile outlier payments was proper and, since the Contractor waited 5 years after discovering the error before notifying the Provider, whether the law bars recovery of the overpayment.
2020D14
17-0654, 17-0656
04-1331
Issue 1 - Whether the use of total costs, rather than patient days, as a statistic to allocate home office pooled costs was proper. Issue 2 - Whether the use of gross revenues, rather than patient days, as a statistic to functionally allocate business of...
2020D13
15-3312
17-1582
Whether the Medicare Contractor's amended hospice cap calculation issued pursuant to the Notice of Reopening properly calculated the Provider's hospice aggregate cap overpayment when it included in "the amount of payment made" certain funds that were sequ...
2020D12
17-1190
24-0052
Whether the Medicare Contractor's final determination of the Provider's Sole Community Hospital ("SCH") Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") was properly calculated.
2020D11
16-2515
50-0072
Whether the Medicare Contractor was correct in calculating the Provider's Sole Community Hospital ("SCH") Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA").
2020D10
17-0184
25-0044
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor ("MAC") determination of the Provider's Medicare Dependent Hospital ("MDH") Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") was calculated in accordance with the regulations at 42 C.F.R. § 412.108 (d) and Program Reimbur...
2020D09
17-0187
25-0044
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor's ("MAC") determination of the Provider's Medicare Dependent Hospital ("MDH") Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") was calculated in accordance with the regulations at 42 C.F.R. § 412.108(d) and Program Reimbu...
2020D08
15-1656, 15-3267, 17-0608, 18-0376, 18-0374
02-0008
Whether the contributions made by the state of Alaska can be counted as "reasonable cost" by the Bartlett Regional Hospital ("Bartlett" or "Provider") for purposes of reimbursement under the Medicare Rural Demonstration Project?
2020D07
16-2051
37-0002
The dispute in this appeal relates to the methodology and calculations used to determine the Provider's fiscal year ("FY") 2011 Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") payment.
2020D06
14-4128
37-0002
The sole disputed issue in this appeal is the methodology used to calculate the Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") payment.
2020D05
15-0359, 15-0909, 16-1527
22-0110
Issue 1 – Whether the Medicare Contractor improperly disallowed the Provider’s reasonable cost for the Ultrasound Allied Health Clinical Training Program that is not operated by the Provider. Issue 2 – Whether the Medicare Contractor improperly dis...
2020D04
13-1221
26-0022
Whether Northeast Regional Medical Center (“Northeast” or the “Provider”), as a Sole Community hospital (“SCH”), was properly reimbursed for indirect medical education costs for services provided to Medicare Advantage (“MA”) patients for t...
2020D03
19-2424GC
05-1770, 05-1746
Whether the MAC’s inclusion of sequestered payments in the determination of the Providers’ Cap on Overall Medicare Reimbursement was proper.
2020D02
17-1827
34-0151
The sole disputed issue in this appeal is the methodology used to calculate the Volume Decrease Adjustment (“VDA”) payment.
2020D01
17-1826
34-0151
The sole disputed issue in this appeal is the methodology used to calculate the Volume Decrease Adjustment (“VDA”) payment.
2019D38
15-0887
26-0022
Whether Northeast Regional Medical Center ("Northeast" or "Provider"), as a Sole Community Hospital ("SCH"), was properly reimbursed for indirect medical education costs for services provided to Medicare Advantage patients for the fiscal year ending May 3...
2019D37
16-1265
10-1543
Whether the Medicare Contractor incorrectly determined the cap year 2012 aggregate cap amount for Seasons Hospice & Palliative Care of Southern Florida ("Seasons" or "Hospice") when the Medicare Contractor used the patient-by-patient proportional method (...
2019D36
13-0929, 13-3153, 13-3155, 13-3156 and 15-1780
52-0098
Issue 1: Whether the Medicare Contractor's adjustments, decreasing the Provider's direct Graduate Medical Education ("GME") and Indirect Medical Education ("IME") Full Time Equivalent ("FTE") Caps to a level below the Provider's audited and adjusted fisca...
2019D35
18-1391
06-0107
Whether the Provider should be subject to a one-fourth reduction in its Federal Fiscal Year ("FFY") 2019 Annual Percentage Update ("APU") for noncompliance with the Hospital Inpatient Quality Reporting ("IQR") Program requirements.
2019D34
07-2227GC; 07-2762GC; and 08-1704GC
Various
Whether the Providers engaged in "reasonable collection efforts," notwithstanding their differential treatment of Medicare and non-Medicare bad debts, in light of the Board's decisions in Reed City Hosp. v. BlueCross BlueShield Ass'n ("Reed City") and St....
2019D33
17-1237GC
Various
Whether the Medicare Contractor's adjustments disallowing the administrative and general costs ("A&G") that Mercy Medical Center - Sioux City ("MMC-SC") allocated to the appealing group members (Baum Harmon Mercy Hospital and Oakland Mercy Hospital) were ...
2019D32
17-1878
11-0032
The sole issue in this appeal is the methodology used to calculate the Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") payment.
2019D31
17-1879
11-0032
The sole disputed issue in this appeal is the methodology used to calculate the Volume Decrease Adjustment ("VDA") payment.
2019D30
18-0934
29-1502
Whether the imposition of a two percent reduction in the fiscal year ("FY") 2018 Medicare payments for Southwest Medical Associates Hospice and Palliative Care ("SMA" or "Provider") was proper.
2019D29
13-0122GC
Various
Whether the Medicare Contractor's must-bill policy applies to the Providers' dual eligible bad debts when the Providers did not participate in the Medicaid program.
2019D28
15-3457GC
Various
Whether the Medicare administrative contractor's inclusion of the sequestered payments never actually paid to the Providers in its calculation of the Providers' hospice cap liabilities was improper.
2019D27
17-1392
23-0092
Did the Medicare Contractor properly calculate the per-resident amount ("PRA") for Medicare payment of direct graduate medical education ("DGME")?
2019D26
16-0140
67-1710
1.) Whether the sequestration amount should be included when calculating the aggregate payment made to Novus Health Services ("Novus" or "Provider") as the reduction in payment through sequestration does not constitute actual Medicare payments made to Nov...
2019D25
17-1221
45-7803
Whether the Centers for Medicare & Medcaid Services properly reduced Abundant Home Health, LLC's home health market basket percentage increase by two percentage points for Calendar Year ("CY") 2017.
2019D24
08-2810, 09-0523, 08-2100
42-0036
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly disallowed all costs and removed all therapy charges relating to the Provider's use of a Therapy and Management Services subcontractor for its Skilled Nursing Facility ("SNF") and Inpatient Rehabilitation Facility ...
2019D23
17-0638
05-0205
Whether the payment penalty imposed by CMS [Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services] under the Hospital Inpatient Quality Reporting ("IQR") program to reduce the Provider's payment update for federal fiscal year 2017 by one-fourth of the annual market ba...
2019D22
15-3311, 16-2022, 16-2024
10-1313
Whether the Medicare Contractor improperly disallowed costs incurred by the Provider under its service agreements with emergency and anesthesiologist physicians groups for availability, standby, and administrative services furnished to the hospital.
2019D21
18-0421
10-8422
Whether RX Home Health Services, Inc. ("RX" or "Provider") should be subject to a two percentage point reduction to its Calendar Year ("CY") 2018 Annual Payment Update ("APU") for failure to meet Home Health Quality Reporting Program requirements in accor...
2019D20
16-1235GC
Various
Whether National Government Services ("Medicare Contractor" or "NGS") erred in calculating the hospice aggregate cap overpayments when it included, in "the amount of payment made," certain funds that were sequestered and never paid to the Providers.
2019D19
18-1292
17-4020
Whether Cottonwood Springs, LLC ("Cottonwood" or "Provider") is entitled to the full market basket adjustment to its Inpatient Psychiatric Facility Prospective Payment System ("IPF PPS") rate for fiscal year 2018.
2019D18
15-2875GC, 15-3271GC
Various
Whether National Government Services ("Medicare Contractor" or "NGS")erred in calculating the hospice aggregate cap overpayments when it included, in "the amount of payment made," certain funds that were sequestered and never paid to the Providers.
2019D17
17-1223
11-2018
Whether the payment penalty that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") imposed under the Long Term Care Hospital Quality Reporting Program ("LTCH-QRP") to reduce the Provider's payment update for Fiscal Year ("FY") 2017 by 2-percent was pro...
2019D16
17-1255
46-2006
Whether the payment penalty that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") imposed under the Long Term Care Hospital Quality Reporting Program ("LTCH-QRP") to reduce the Provider's payment update for Fiscal Year ("FY") 2017 by 2-percent was pro...
2019D15
13-0820, 13-1873
42-0004
Issue 1: Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor's decision to reclassify the costs and statistics out of the paramedical pass-through cost center was proper. This issue applies to the fiscal years ending June 30, 2007 ("FY 2007") and June 30, 200...
2019D14
18-0508
36-0245
Whether the fiscal year ("FY") 2018 penalty imposed under the hospital inpatient quality reporting ("IQR") program was proper.
2019D13
17-1238
12-3025
Whether the reduction to the Provider's Market Basket Update for the fiscal year ("FY") 2017 under the Inpatient Rehabilitation Facility ("IRF") Quality Reporting Program ("QRP") was proper.
2019D12
13-0252 & 14-3256
15-1318
Whether the Medicare Contractor appropriately disallowed costs to the Provider claimed for physician compensation for emergency room availibility services (frequently referred to as "standby services"), administrative/management services, and on-call cost...
2019D11
14-3883G, 14-3890G, 14-3894G, 14-3896G, 14-3897G, 14-3899G, 14-0259 & 14-0266
Various
Whether the Medicare Contractor's determination to reduce the Providers' indirect medical education ("IME") and graduate medical education ("GME") full-time equivalent ("FTE") resident counts to exclude certain resident rotations in nonhospital clinics wa...
2019D10
18-1034
24-1582
Whether the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services properly reduced Minnesota Hospice, LLC's annual payment update ("APU") for Fiscal Year ("FY") 2018 by 2 percentage points.
2019D09
17-1958
31-4019
Whether Christian Health Care Center (d/b/a Ramapo Ridge Psychiatric Hospital ("Ramapo Ridge" or "Provider")) is entitled to the full market basket adjustment to its rate for fiscal year ("FY") 2017.
2019D08
12-0404G, 12-0450G, 12-0456GC, 12-0457GC, 12-0449GC, 12-0454GC
Various
Whether the Federal Fiscal Year ("FFY") 2012 wage index factor and capital geographic adjustment factor for Core Based Statistical Area ("CBSA") No. 40900 used in the calculation of Medicare inpatient and outpatient prospective payments is properly stated...
2019D07
17-0820
25-T004
Whether the reduction of the Provider's Annual Payment Update ("APU") by 2 percent for fiscal year ("FY") 2017 was proper.
2019D06
18-0460
45-0152
Whether the payment penalty under the Hospital Inpatient Quality Reporting Program was properly applied to the Provider.
2019D05
13-2991, 13-3853
14-0224
Did National Government Services, the Medicare Administrative Contractor, properly determine the count of full-time equivalent residents ("FTEs"), used for the purposes of calculating payments for direct graduate medical education ("DGME"), indirect medic...
2019D04
17-0685
42-8960
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor's ("Medicare Contractor") disallowance of the Medicare bad debts claimed by Mackey Family Practice was proper.
2019D03
10-1176, 11-0252, 11-0733, 12-0400
05-1317
Issue 1 - Whether the costs incurred by the Provider for its physician on-call expenses should be allowed for the four cost reporting periods at issue (2005, 2006, 2007 and 2008). Issue 2 - Whether the Provider's costs of meals furnished to outpatients (...
2019D02
13-1053
45-0044
Whether the Medicare Contractor's audit adjustments to remove Medicare Usable Organs (Heart & Kidney) were fair and proper.
2019D01
17-0646
51-0006
Whether the reduction by one-fourth of the Provider's fiscal year ("FY") 2017 Inpatient Prospective Payment System annual payment update for the failure to meet all of the inpatient quality reporting requirements is proper.
2018D52
14-3942
24-0101
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor was correct when it calculated the Provider's volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") by prorating the amount of the VDA according to the portion of the year during which the Provider maintained sole community hos...
2018D51
14-3941
24-0088
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor was correct when it calculated the Provider's volume decrease adjustment ("VDA") by prorating the amount of the VDA according to the portion of the year during which the Provider maintained sole community hos...
2018D50
13-0430, 13-0628, 13-0680
05-0231
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor properly calculated Pomona Valley Hospital Medical Center's disproportionate share hospital reimbursement with respect to the Provider's Supplemental Security Income percentage.
2018D49
13-1460GC, 14-0565GC, 14-0773GC & 14-3216GC
Various
Whether a certain category of Medicaid waiver days should be included in the numerator of the Medicaid fraction used to calculate the Providers' disproportionate share hospital ("DSH") payments. The specific days at issue are attributable to patients who...
2018D48
09-0937GC
Various
Should patient days associated with Medicare Part A and Title XIX eligible patients that were not included in the SSI percentage factor of the Medicare Disproportionate Share formula be included in the Medicaid fraction of the Medicare DSH formula?
2018D47
17-1018
45-2061
Whether the payment penalty that CMS imposed under the Long-Term Care Hospital Quality Reporting Program to reduce the Provider's payment update for the federal fiscal year of 2017 by two percent was proper.
2018D46
13-2321; 13-2323; 13-3154; 15-3191
19-0064
When the Medicare Contractor recalculates the Provider's per-resident amount ("PRA"), whether it is consistent with the law to use 1998 census region hospital data to determine the cap on the Provider's recalculated PRA?
2018D45
13-0489
33-0044
The Provider contends that the disallowance of the bad debts claimed is not in accordance with the Medicare regulations and manual provisions as described in the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services' ("CMS") Provider Reimbursement Manual ("PRM"), CMS ...
2018D44
17-0196
23-0244/23-T244
Whether the Provider timely submitted required quality data during the required timeframes, and is entitled to the full Market Basket Update for Fiscal Year ("FY") 2017?
2018D43
08-2598G; 08-2955GC; 13-0016G
Various
Should patient days associated with Medicare Part A, Title XIX eligible patients that were not included in the Supplemental Security Income ("SSI") percentage factor of the Medicare Disproportionate Share Hospital ("DSH") formula be included in the Medica...
2018D42
17-1167
04-3033
Conway Regional Rehabilitation Hospital ("Conway" or the "Provider") challenges the reduction of its Annual Payment Update ("APU") for the federal fiscal year ("FFY") 2017 by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") under the Inpatient Rehabil...
2018D41
13-1588
44-0193
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor ("Medicare Contractor") determined Medicare reimbursement for Disproportionate Share Hospital ("DSH") payments in accordance with the Medicare statute, 42 U.S.C. § 1395ww(d)(5)(F)(vi). Specifically, whether...
2018D40
17-1266
49-7591
Whether the imposition of a two percent reduction in the appealing home health agency’s (“HHA’s”) Medicare payments for calendar year (“CY”) 2017 was proper.
2018D39
17-0854
05-9656
Whether Grace Community Home Health, Inc., (“Grace Community” or “Provider”) should be subject to a two percentage point reduction to its calendar year (“CY”) 2017 home health market basket percentage increase1 for failure to meet the Home Hea...
2018D38
17-0866
34-0047/34-T047
Whether a two percentage point reduction in the Provider’s fiscal year (“FY”) 2017 annual increase factor, due to failure to meet Inpatient Rehabilitation Facility Quality Reporting Program (“IRF-QRP”) requirements, was proper?
2018D37
16-0828
33-1542
Hospice Care in Westchester and Putnam, Inc. (“Hospice Care” or the “Provider”) challenges the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ (“CMS’”) reduction to the Provider’s Annual Payment Update (“APU”) for Fiscal Year (“FY”) 20...
2018D36
13-1575; 13-2481; 13-2518
23-0070
Whether, for purposes of the graduate medical education (“GME”) payment and indirect medical education (“IME”) adjustments for FYE’s 06/30/2007, 06/30/2008 and 06/30/2009, the Provider is entitled to count full time equivalent (“FTE”) reside...
2018D35
15-3416
36-0006
Whether the determination that the Riverside Methodist Hospital (“Riverside” or “Provider”) failed to meet the validation requirements for the Calendar Year (“CY”) 2015 Hospital Outpatient Quality Reporting (“HOQR”) Program was proper.
2018D34
15-3197
46-0047
Whether the Provider is entitled to the full Outpatient Prospective Payment System (“OPPS”) market basket rate for Calendar Year (“CY”) 2015 based on its reported Hospital Outpatient Quality Reporting (“HOQR”) validation data?
2018D33
14-3449; 14-3627 and 15-3186
23-0142
Whether the Provider is entitled to higher Graduate Medical Education (“GME”) and Indirect Medical Education (“IME”) full-time equivalent (“FTE”) resident caps for a new Family Medicine residents training Program?
2018D32
16-0159
05-1763
Whether the imposition of a two percent reduction in Lightbridge Hospice?s (?Lightbridge? or ?Provider?) fiscal year (FY) 2016 Medicare payments was proper.
2018D31
17-1253
23-3026
Whether the Provider is entitled to the full market basket update for Fiscal Year (“FY”) 2017.
2018D30
16-0143
52-1531
Whether the imposition of a two percent reduction in Horizon Home Care & Hospice, Inc.’s (“Horizon” or “Provider”) fiscal year (“FY”) 2016 Medicare payments was proper.
2018D29
04-1447; 05-2052; 06-1034
36-0151
Whether the Medicare Contractor’s adjustments to the Provider’s available beds and bed days and prior-year resident-to-bed ratio for cost reporting periods ending 6/30/2001, 6/30/2002 and 6/30/2003 were proper.
2018D28
08-1553, 09-1533, 09-2222
50-0054
Whether the Medicare Contractor improperly disallowed reimbursement for direct graduate medical education (“GME”) and indirect medical education (“IME”) costs in the non-hospital setting by reducing the Provider’s full-time equivalent (“FTE”...
2018D27
17-0564
16-0001
Whether the Provider is entitled to the full Market Basket Update for the fiscal year (?FY?) 2017.
2018D26
17-0301
25-0099
Whether the reduction of the Provider’s Market Basket Update for federal fiscal year (“FY”) 2017 under the Hospital Inpatient Quality Reporting (“IQR”) Program was proper?
2018D25
13-2696; 14-0033; 14-0031; 15-0072; 15-0827; 15-3347
33-0136
Whether Mary Imogene Bassett Hospital (“Mary Imogene” or “Hospital”), as a Sole Community Hospital (“SCH”), was properly reimbursed for Indirect Medical Education (“IME”) costs for services provided to Medicare Advantage (“MA” or “Pa...
2018D24
15-0414
10-0284
Whether the payment reduction to the market basket update that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (“CMS”) imposed under the Hospital Inpatient Quality Reporting (“IQR”) program for fiscal year (“FY”) 2015 was proper?
2018D23
13-0043
14-5713
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor’s (“Medicare Contractor’s”) adjustment that eliminated $183,879 of claimed Medicare reimbursable bad debts was proper and in accordance with Medicare regulations and the Centers for Medicare and Medic...
2018D22
14-0682G; 14-1124G
Various
Whether the Low-Income Pool Section 1115 waiver days should be included in the Medicaid fraction of the Low Income Patient (?LIP?) calculations.
2018D21
09-0580GC; 13-3376G; 14-0871GC; 14-3832GC;15-0446G; 15-3474GC; 14-0645G
Various
Whether the Low-Income Pool Section 1115 waiver days should be included in the Medicaid fraction of the disproportionate share hospital (?DSH?) calculations.
2018D20
08-1052G
18-0038, 18-0130, 18-0138, 18-0104, 18-0103, 18-0080
Whether the inclusion of surgical technicians, mental health technicians, and heart center recovery technicians in the “All other occupations” category instead of the “Nursing aides, orderlies and attendants” category in the Provider’s occupatio...
2018D19
09-2156GC
Various
Whether the Providers are entitled to reimbursement of their Medicare bad debts for the fiscal years ending December 31, 2001, 2002 and 2003.
2018D18
08-0105GC
44-0176 and 44-0063
Whether the Providers engaged in “reasonable collection efforts” notwithstanding their differential treatment of Medicare and non-Medicare bad debt, in light of the Reed City and St. Francis Board decisions?
2018D17
07-1015
06-0104
Did the Medicare Contractor improperly reduce the Provider’s adjusted indirect medical education (“IME”) full time equivalent (“FTE”) count from 6.48 to zero?
2018D16
16-2080
33-0108
Whether the Provider should be subjected to a reduction of one quarter of the market basket update to the fiscal year (?FY?) 2017 Inpatient Prospective Payment System (?IPPS?) rates for the failure to meet the Hospital Inpatient Quality Reporting (?IQR?) ...
2018D15
07-1589G, 08-1344G and 09-1283G
Various
Whether the Medicare Contractor should have excluded the aberrant wage index data from Brunswick Hospital Center (“Brunswick”) when calculating the Nassau-Suffolk Core-Based Statistical Area (“CBSA”) wage index calculations for fiscal years (“FY...
2018D14
15-1033
33-1990
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor (“Medicare Contractor”), Cahaba Safeguard Administrators, LLC (“Cahaba”) improperly reclassified Provider costs related to providing housing free of charge for temporary, on-call and other staff, and ...
2018D13
17-1310
34-0098
Whether the full reduction of the Provider’s annual increase factor by 2 percent for fiscal year (“FY”) 2017 for failing to timely submit one of the six required data under the Inpatient Rehabilitation Facility (“IRF”) Quality Reporting Program ...
2018D12
14-2968
37-0037
Whether the Medicaid days attributable to child and adolescent patients who received services in three of the Provider’s inpatient behavioral health units (namely the ACCENTS Unit, the Human Restoration Unit, and the Positive Outcomes Unit) can be inclu...
2018D11
11-0142
19-4653
Was the Medicare Contractor’s adjustment to the Provider’s bad debts claimed proper?
2018D10
09-0233
19-4653
Was the Medicare Contractor’s adjustment to the Provider’s bad debts claimed proper?
2018D09
16-0395
33-0132
Whether the reduction of the Provider?s Market Basket Update for federal fiscal year (?FY?) 2016 under the Hospital Inpatient Quality Reporting (?IQR?) Program was proper?
2018D08
09-0915G
Various
Whether the Supplemental Security Income (?SSI?) ratio used to calculate the Medicare Low Income Patient (?LIP?) adjustment for inpatient rehabilitation facilities (?IRFs?) accurately reflects the number of patient days corresponding to the IRF cost repor...
2018D07
10-0033
51-1318
Whether the Medicare Contractor improperly calculated and adjusted Montgomery General Hospital’s (“Montgomery” or “Provider”) defined benefit pension plan contribution cost that the Provider claimed on its fiscal year 2007 cost report.
2018D06
10-0991GC; 10-1158GC
Various
Whether the Medicare Contractor’s adjustment to the Clinical Pastoral Education (“CPE”) costs from being reported as an allied health educational activity to an administrative and general expense is correct.
2018D05
08-0585GC; 09-1589GC; 10-0090GC; 11-0028GC; 12-0147GC; 13-2822GC; 14-1622GC; 15-3239GC and 16-1252GC
Various
Whether the Providers may be reimbursed for bad debts incurred by patients who were dually eligible for Medicare and Medicaid.
2018D04
16-1544 and 17-0193
36-0148
Whether the Medicare Contractor’s adjustments to the Provider’s Electronic Health Record (“EHR”) incentive payment based on the exclusion of inpatient days for which the Provider provided covered services to Medicare Advantage (“MA”) patients ...
2018D03
09-0890 and 10-1102
37-2007
Whether the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid (“CMS”) must-bill policy applies to the Provider’s crossover bad debts where the Provider did not participate in the Medicaid Program.
2018D02
17-0865
74-7761
Whether Canine Friendly Coalition, Inc. d/b/a Desert Star Home Health (“Desert Star” or “Provider”) should be subject to a two percent reduction to its calendar year (“CY”) 2017 home health market basket percentage increase for failure to me...
2018D01
14-1248 and 15-1445
16-1325
Whether the Wisconsin Physician Services (“Medicare Contractor”) improperly disallowed certain home office costs claimed by Greene County Medical Center (“Greene” or “Provider”) on the grounds that it was not related to the entity that had fur...
2017D31
13-3331, 14-1269 and 14-3176
16-1305
Whether the Wisconsin Physician Services (“Medicare Contractor”)1 improperly disallowed certain home office costs claimed by Pocahontas Community Hospital (“Pocahontas or Provider”) on the grounds that it was not related to the entity that had fur...
2017D30
13-0633
22-0066
Whether Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ (“CMS”) June 27, 2012 determination that Mercy Medical Center (“Mercy” or “Provider”) did not meet the quality reporting program requirements for Fiscal Year (“FY”) 2013 and that its fai...
2017D29
15-2800
10-0106
Whether the payment penalty that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (?CMS?) imposed under the Hospital Inpatient Quality Reporting (?IQR?) program to reduce the Provider?s payment update for fiscal year (?FY?) 2016 by twenty-five percent of the ...
2017D28
09-0454
29-0021
Whether the Medicare Contractor’s exclusion of Medicare Advantage/HMO charges and days from the calculation of the direct graduate medical education (“DGME”) payment for Valley Hospital Medical Center (“Valley” or “Provider”) for its fiscal ...
2017D27
05-0202 and 06-0933
33-0125
Whether the Provider is entitled to a temporary increase in its resident full time equivalent (“FTE”) count due to the closing of one of the other three hospitals in a medical education training program.
2017D26
13-3169
05-0174
Whether Santa Rosa Memorial Hospital’s (“Santa Rosa” or Provider”) Medicaid eligible days for the low-income patient (“LIP”) adjustment for FY 2008 are correctly stated?
2017D25
13-1196, 13-1198 and 13-0900
10-0007
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor properly disallowed a portion of the Hospital’s indigent bad debts claimed for the cost reporting periods for fiscal years (“FYs”) ending December 31, 2006, December 31, 2007 and December 31, 2008, on t...
2017D24
13-0009
18-0070
Whether the decision by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (“CMS”) to impose a 2 percent reduction to the Market Basket Update for fiscal year (“FY”) 2013 for Twin Lakes Regional Medical Center (“Provider” or “Twin Lakes”) , wh...
2017D23
15-2948
10-9401
Whether Millennium Home Care, LLC (“Provider” or “MHC”) should be subject to a 2 percent reduction in home health prospective payment system payments for calendar year (“CY”) 2015 in accordance with 42 C.F.R. § 484.225(i) (2013).
2017D22
13-2636GC, 13-2637GC,13-2640GC
Various
Whether the Medicare Contractor’s revised determination that the Iowa Critical Access Hospitals (“Iowa CAHs” or “Providers”) are not related to Mercy Medical Center-Des Moines (“Mercy”), and all cost report adjustments stemming from that det...
2017D21
15-1873, 15-1880
45-2060, 49-2009
Whether the payment penalty that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (“CMS”) imposed under the Long-Term Care Hospital Quality Reporting Program (“LTCH QRP”) to reduce the Provider’s payment update for Fiscal Year (“FY”) 2015 by 2...
2017D20
13-1203
17-0086
Whether the Provider, Stormont-Vail Healthcare, Inc. (“Stormont-Vail”), was the legal operator of Baker University Nursing School pursuant to 42 C.F.R. § 413.85(f)(1) (2008), thus qualifying under the Medicare program for pass-through reimbursement f...
2017D19
14-3177, 14-1331 and 15-0165
16-1348
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor (“Medicare Contractor”),1 Wisconsin Physicians Service (“WPS”), improperly disallowed certain home office costs claimed by the Provider, Clarke County Hospital (“Clarke”), on the grounds that it w...
2017D18
15-1879
15-2027
Whether the payment penalty that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (?CMS?) imposed under the Long-Term Care Hospital Quality Reporting Program (?LTCH QRP?) to reduce the Provider?s payment update for Fiscal Year (?FY?) 2015 by 2 percent was p...
2017D17
13-0196G, 13-3892G,14-1723G and 15-1946G
Various
Was the use of Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ (“CMS”) sequential geography methodology (“SGM”) for setting the Providers’ base year per resident amounts (“PRAs”) for Medicare reimbursement of certain graduate medical education...
2017D16
15-2721
19-0081
Whether the reduction of West Carroll Memorial Hospital’s (“West Carroll” or “Provider”)annual payment update for calendar year (“CY”) 2015 under the hospital outpatient quality reporting (“Hospital OQR”) program was proper.
2017D15
15-0660
15-3043
Whether the Provider satisfied Inpatient Rehabilitation Facility (“IRF”) Quality Reporting Program (“QRP”) requirements applicable to it during its first year of Medicare participation such that it would be entitled to the full market basket1 rate...
2017D14
10-1036
05-4662
Whether Portia Bell Hume Behavioral Health & Training Center (“Hume Center”) can be paid by the Medicare program for certain dual eligible Medicare and Medicaid crossover bad debts without billing and obtaining a remittance advice (“RA”) from the ...
2017D13
10-1018GC
Various
Whether the Providers can claim Medicare and Medicaid crossover bad debts for reimbursement without billing the appropriate state agency.
2017D12
07-0413, 07-2872G, 09-1039GC, 09-1830G, 09-1863GC, 12-0365GC, 12-0373GC, 12-0412, 13-0140GC, 13-0591, 15-0266 and 15-0270
Various
Whether Medicare Disproportionate Share Hospital (“DSH”) reimbursement calculations for the Providers (“Hospitals”) were understated due to the failure of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (“CMS”) and the relevant Medicare administr...
2017D11
13-1862GC, et al.
Various
Whether the Medicare Disproportionate Share Hospital (“DSH”) reimbursement calculations for the Providers (“Hospitals”) were understated due to the failure of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (“CMS”) and the relevant Medicare Admin...
2017D10
15-0839
33-1520
The Provider appeals the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ (“CMS”)determination that the Provider is subject to a reduced Federal Fiscal Year (“FY”) 2015 Annual Payment Update (“APU”) under the Hospice Quality Reporting Program(“H...
2017D09
10-0015
25-1318
Whether the Intermediary’s reduction to the Provider’s fiscal year ending September 30, 2007(“FY 2007”) cost report to disallow Medicare bad debts related to the Provider’s geropsychiatric program was proper?
2017D08
11-0124
19-4069
Whether the Provider is entitled to blended reimbursement for its fiscal year end (“FYE”)December 31, 2008 cost report under 42 C.F.R. § 412.426(a)(3).
2017D07
10-0896
13-0007
Whether the Medicare Contractor’s adjustments disallowing Saint Alphonsus’ claimed reimbursement for GME and IME costs in the non-hospital setting, by reducing its FTE count because Saint Alphonsus shared these costs with another hospital, was proper.
2017D06
06-2131; 10-0547
45-2072
Whether the Medicare Contractor?s adjustment to apply the ?must-bill? policy to bad debts related to dual eligible Medicare and Medicaid beneficiaries was proper.
2017D05
15-0146; 16-0811
45-0389
Whether the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (‘CMS”) have assigned the Provider to the correct Core Based Statistical Area (“CBSA”) for the Federal Fiscal Year (“FFY”) 2015.
2017D04
14-1394GC; 14-1732GC
Various
Whether days attributable to patients who were eligible for, and received, assistance through the Massachusetts Commonwealth Care Health Insurance Program (“CCHIP”), a CMS-approved § 1115 waiver, should be included in the numerator of the Medicaid f...
2017D03
15-1819
19-2031
Whether the payment penalty imposed by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (?CMS?) to reduce Cornerstone Hospital West Monroe?s Fiscal Year (?FY?) 2015 Medicare payment by 2 percent was proper?
2017D02
03-1599G
15-5443; 15-5246; 15-5280; 15-5233; 15-5202; 15-5217; 15-5304; 15-5483; 15-5409; 15-5238, 45-5947
Whether the Medicare Contractor’s methodology allocating Park Associates pooled home office costs improperly denied reimbursement to the Providers?
2017D01
13-1012
16-0016
Whether Trinity Regional Medical Center (?Trinity? or ?Provider?) was entitled to a Volume Decrease Adjustment (?VDA?)?
2016D27
13-1119; 14-2753
10-0271
Did the Medicare Contractor properly calculate the cancer center's payment-to-cost ratio ("PCR") for both fiscal years ("FYs") under appeal?
2016D26
09-1541G
Various
Did the Medicare Contractor properly reduce the Hospitals' Indirect Medical Education ("IME") Full Time Equivalent ("FTE") resident counts, for time spent by residents in research activities?
2016D25
10-0988; 10-0989; 09-0320; 09-0330GC; 09-2117GC; 12-0057; 11-0569GC; 14-2864; 13-2360GC; 15-2603
Various
Whether the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services' ("CMS") must-bill policy applies to the Providers' dual-eligible bad debts when the Providers did not participate in Medicaid.
2016D24
15-1975
45-2116
Whether the payment penalty that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") imposed under the Long-Term Care Hospital Quality Reporting Program to reduce the Provider's update for Fiscal Year ("FY") 2016 by 2 percent was proper.
2016D23
15-2051
46-7213
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly imposed a 2 percent payment reduction upon Valeo Home Health Services, Inc. for calendar year ("CY") 2015 for failure to submit quality data as required by the Deficit Reduction Act of 2005.
2016D22
08-0252GC; 08-1945GC; 09-1473GC; 10-1130GC; 11-0590GC
Various
Whether the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") must-bill policy applies to the Providers' dual eligible bad debts when the Providers did not participate in the Medicaid Program.
2016D21
13-3307; 14-1004; 14-1760; 15-1894
44-0048
Whether the Medicare Contractor's disallowance of the costs for the Hospital's Allied Health Care Management Program ("AHCMP") was correct.
2016D20
04-1952; 06-2367; 08-1595; 08-1951; 11-0132
45-0076
Issue 1 - Whether the Provider's request for adjustments to the TEFRA target amount shall be granted. Issue 2 - Whether the Medicare Contractor's adjustment to certain Company P expenses was proper.
2016D19
09-0543
25-0040
Whether, in calculating the Medicaid fraction of the Medicare DSH percentage, the Medicare Contractor improperly excluded the inpatient days related to individuals eligible for either expanded Medicaid eligibility or Uncompensated Care Pool services under...
2016D18
10-1020G
25-0078, 25-0097
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly excluded the Hospitals' patient days attributable to Mississippi's § 1115 Waiver, from the calculation of the Hospitals' disproportionate share hospital ("DSH") percentage.
2016D17
07-0637GC, 08-1019GC, 08-0258GC, 10-0249GC, 13-1238GC, 14-0003GC, 14-2395GC, 14-3725GC, 15-0196GC
Various
Whether patient days which the appealing Providers have identified as "inactive" in the Colorado Medicaid program should be included in the Medicaid proxy that is used in the calculation of the Medicare payment for disproportionate share hospitals ("DSH")...
2016D16
12-0031
16-0005
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor (Medicare Contractor) correctly determined the amount of the Sole Community Hospital ("SCH") volume decrease adjustment in accordance with the regulations and Program instructions per 42 C.F.R. § 412.92(e)(3...
2016D15
07-2449G
25-1560; 25-1565
Whether the Medicare Contractor used the proper date to start the running of the 3-year reopening period for the 2003 hospice cap calculation by CMS for the cap tear ending October 31, 2003 (November 1, 2002 through October 31, 2003)?
2016D14
07-1992GC
37-0032, 37-0028
Was the Medicare Contractor's exclusion of all of the family practice interns and residents for each of the Hospitals from their respective full time equivalent ("FTE") counts and Medicare Contractor's denial of the associated indirect medical education (...
2016D13
07-0631
05-0017
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly calculated the amount of the Provider's exception to the routine cost limits ("RCL") for hospital-based skilled nursing facilities ("HB-SNF") by excluding from that calculation those costs that were above the RCL b...
2016D12
10-1377, 10-1375
23-0130
Whether the William Beaumont Hospital, Royal Oak ("Beaumont") submitted sufficient documentation for its non-Provider-operated nurse clinical training program costs to support pass-through reimbursement for fiscal years (FYs") 2005 and 2006.
2016D11
06-0213, 05-2117, 06-0167, 07-0976, 08-0181, 08-1846, 08-2830
18-0141
1. DIDACTIC TIME-Whether the Medicare Contractor's exclusion of didactic time from the FTE counts for indirect medical education ("IME") and direct graduate medical education ("DGME") for fiscal years ("FYs") 2000 to 2006 was appropriate.; 2. DENTAL FOREI...
2016D10
15-1874
22-2043
Whether the payment penalty that the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") imposed under the Long-Term Care Hospital Quality Reporting Program to reduce the Provider's payment update for Fiscal Year ("FY") 2015 by two percent was proper?
04-1952, 06-2367, 08-1595, 08-1951
45-0076
1.Whether the Provider's request for adjustments to the TEFRA target amount shall be granted.; 2.Whether the Medicare Contractor's adjustment to certain Company P expenses was proper.
2016D08
15-0199
26-2020
Whether the payment penalty that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services ("CMS") imposed under the Long-Term Care Hospital Quality Reporting Program to reduce the Provider's update for Fiscal Year ("FY") 2015 by two percent was proper?
2016D07
09-0939GC
14-T007, 14-T217
Does the Provider Reimbursement Review Board ("Board") have jurisdiction to review the Medicare Contractor's determination of the low-income patient ("LIP") adjustment for Provena St. Joseph Medical Center and Provena St. Joseph Hospital (collectively "Pr...
2016D06
03-1202G; 07-2262G and 07-2263G
Various
Whether secondary MediKan days should have been included in the Provider's Medicaid fraction for the Disproportionate Share Hospital ("DSH") calculation in the disputed cost reports.
2016D05
15-0204
10-2021
Whether the payment penalty that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services ("CMS") imposed under the Long-Term Care Hospital Quality Reporting Program to reduce the Provider's payment update for Fiscal Year ("FY") 2015 by two percent was proper?
2016D04
09-0101
05-0006
Does the Provider Reimbursement Review Board ("Board") have jurisdiction to review the Medicare Contractor's determination of the low-income patient ("LIP") adjustment pertaining to fiscal year ("FY") 2007 for St. Joseph Hospital of Eureka ("St. Joseph")?
2016D03
11-0625
16-0147
Whether the Medicare Contractor properly denied the request of Grinnell Regional Medical Center ("Grinnell" or "Provider") for a volume decrease payment adjustment.
2016D02
15-2901
05-0009
Does the Provider Reimbursement Review Board ("Board") have jurisdiction to review the Medicare Contractor's determination of the number of Medicaid eligible days included in the numerator of the low-income patient ("LIP") adjustment for Queen of the Vall...
2016D01
05-0543GC, 05-0862GC and 06-0910GC
Various
Whether inpatient days for Medicaid-eligible patients who were enrolled in a Medicare+Choice ("M+C") plan under Medicare Part C were properly excluded from the numerator of the Medicaid fraction that is used to calculate the disproportionate share hospita...
2015D30
11-0121GC
Various
Does the Provider Reimbursement Review Board ("Board") have jurisdiction to review the Medicare Contractor's determination of low-income patient ("LIP") adjustment for Baptist Memorial Hospital-Germantown and Baptist Memorial Hospital North Mississippi ("...
2015D29
09-0861GC and 09-1942GC
Various
Does the Provider Reimbursement Review Board ("Board") have jurisdiction to review the Medicare Contractor's determination of low-income patient ("LIP") adjustments for the 2006 and 2007 HealthSouth SSI Percentage CIRP Groups ("HealthSouth")?
2015D28
08-0943
05-0498
Does the Provider Reimbursement Review Board ("Board") have jurisdiction to review the Medicare Contractor's determination of low-income patient ("LIP") adjustment pertaining to fiscal year ("FY") 2004 for Sutter Auburn Faith Hospital ("Auburn")?
2015D27
08-0933
05-0498
Does the Provider Reimbursement Review Board ("Board") have jurisdiction to review the Medicare Contractor's determination of low-income patient ("LIP") adjustment pertaining to fiscal year ("FY") 2005 for Sutter Auburn Faith Hospital ("Auburn")?
2015D26
11-0160
10-4993
1. Whether a community mental health center ("CMHC") is a "provider of services" entitled to a hearing before the Provider Reimbursement Review Board ("the Board") under 42 U.S.C. Section 1395oo. 2. If a CMHC is a "provider of services," does this find...
2015D25
08-0143 and 09-0403
33-0044
Whether the Medicare Contractor's adjustment to Faxton - St. Luke's Medicare bad debts was proper?
2015D24
08-1441 and 08-2364
45-0209
Whether the current year bed count and the available bed days were properly recorded for fiscal year ("FY") 2005, and whether the current year bed count and available bed days and the available bed days used to calculate the prior year intern to resident ...
2015D23
98-0212G, et al.
See Appendix A
Whether the Providers had to bill the state Medicaid program and submit a state remittance advice to the Medicare Contractor as a precondition for the Medicare program to pay bad debts for unpaid coinsurance and deductiblees for individuals who are eligib...
2015D22
15-0404
19-0204
Whether the reduction of the Provider's market basket update for federal fiscal year ("FY") 2015 under the Hospital Inpatient Quality Reporting ("IQR)" program was proper?
2015D21
08-0028
34-0168
1. Whether the Medicare Contractor's adjustment to the provider-based physician professional component was proper.; 2. Whether the Medicare Contractor's recoupment of payments related to the denial of inpatient admissions was proper.; 3. Whether the ...
2015D20
07-1509
05-0498
Does the Provider Reimbursement Review Board ("Board") have jurisdiction to review the Medicare Contractor's determination of low-income patient ("LIP") adjustment for Sutter Auburn Faith Hospital ("Auburn") for fiscal year ("FY") 2003? Specifically, Aub...
2015D19
01-2872R
05-2250
Whether the denial of the Provider's request for an exception to the end stage renal disease ("ESRD") composite rate by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services ("CMS") was proper.
2015D18
01-2871R
05-0327
Whether the denial of the Provider's request for an exception to the end stage renal disease ("ESRD") composite rate by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services ("CMS") was proper.
2015D17
15-0203
19-2043
Whether the payment penalty that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services ("CMS") imposed under the Long-Term Care Hospital Quality Reporting Program to reduce the Provider's payment update for Fiscal Year ("FY") 2015 by two percent was proper?
2015D16
08-2387
05-0498
Does the Provider Reimbursement Review Board (“Board”) have jurisdiction to review the Medicare Contractor’s determination of low-income patient (“LIP”) adjustment for Sutter Auburn Faith Hospital (“Auburn”) for fiscal year (“FY”) 2006? ...
05-0543GC; 05-0862GC and 06-0910GC
Various
Whether inpatient days for Medicaid-eligible patients who were enrolled in a Medicare+Choice ("M+C") plan under Medicare Part C were properly excluded from the numerator of the Medicaid fraction that is used to calculate the disproportionate share hospita...
2015D14
08-0362
31-4021
Whether the Medicare Contractor improperly disallowed from the calculation of the Provider's bad debt expense, for the subject fiscal year, bad debts associated with patients whose accounts were not billed to Medicaid prior to the accounts being written o...
2015D13
09-1754
15-0017
Whether the Medicare Contractor's adjustment to remove time for off-site rotations was proper?
2015D12
05-1647
05-0446
Whether the Medicare Contractor's denial of Tehachapi Valley Hospital's ("Tehachapi" or "Provider") request for a low volume adjustment payment under 42 C.F.R. Section 412.92(e) was proper?
2015D11
09-1704
02-0012
Whether the Medicare Contractor's calculation of the Provider's low volume adjustment amount was determined correctly.
2015D10
14-3722
34-7247
Was it proper to impose a 2 percent reduction in the Medicare payments to Liberty Healthcare Group, LLC's home health agency located in Supply, North Carolina for calendar year ("CY") 2014?
2015D09
12-0146
32-0003
Whether the Medicare Contractor's denial of Alta Vista Regional Hospital's ("Alta Vista") request for a sole community hospital volume decrease adjustment payment was proper?
2015D08
08-2169G and 08-2177G
See Appendix A
Whether the exclusion by the Medicare Contractor of days identified as inpatient days attributable to individuals who received medical assistance/general assistance under the Connecticut State Administered General Assistance ("SAGA") Program from the Medi...
2015D07
06-0686; 07-1177; 08-1362
10-0061
Issue 1: Whether the Provider Reimbursement Review Board ("Board") has jurisdiction to review the Medicare Contractor's determination that the days of patients who were both eligible for medical assistance under an approved Medicaid state plan and enroll...
2015D06
04-0492G
Various
Whether the Medicare Contractor and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services ("CMS") properly determined the Santa Cruz, California Metropolitan Statistical Area ("MSA") Wage Index for Federal Fiscal Year ("FFY") 2004.
2015D05
07-0399 and 08-0748
36-0019
For fiscal years ("FYs") 2004 and 2005, does the Provider Reimbursement Review Board (the "Board") have jurisdiction over the Medicaid eligible days issue in the appeals?
2015D04
13-2038; 13-0452; 13-1454G; 11-0518GC; and 11-0497GC
Various (See Appendix A)
Did the Medicare contractor properly offset the Kentucky provider tax assessment ("KP-Tax") for each of the seven hospitals for the fiscal years at issue by the corresponding amount of the Kentucky Medicaid Disproportionate Share Hospital ("Medicaid DSH")...
2015D03
01-0004GE; 04-1492GE; 06-0509GE; 09-2040G
Various (See Appendix I)
This case was remanded to the Board and the parties presented the following issues pursuant to the decision of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ("Ninth Circuit") in Providence Yakima Medical Center v. Sebelius ("Providence Yakima"). The ca...
2015D02
06-1843; 07-1701; 08-1543; 10-0786 and 10-1178
15-1301
Was the Intermediary's disallowance of the interest expense proper for St. Vincent Randolph for the 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007 and 2008 fiscal years?
2015D01
10-0302GC; 06-0662G; 06-2036G; 06-0740G; 07-0271G; 07-0273G; 06-0872G and 06-0873G
Various
Whether the Intermediary's application of the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals' holding in Clark Regional Medical Center v. United States Department of Health and Human Services, 314 F.3d. 241 (6th Cir. 2002) ("Clark") to the determination of the number of ...
2014D30
07-2227GC; 07-2762GC and 08-1704GC
Various
Whether the Intermediary properly disallowed the Providers' non-indigent debts for fiscal year ends 2004, 2005, and 2006, for not meeting all applicable regulatory requirements.
2014D29
08-0050
27-1335
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor's disallowance of the Provider's certified registered nurse anesthetist on-call costs was proper.
2014D28
08-1929GC; 09-0510GC; 11-0568GC
Various
Whether the Intermediary properly applied the weighted discharge cap to the Providers' ancillary costs.
2014D27
05-0553
31-0014
Whether days associated with patients covered under the New Jersey Charity Care Program should be included in the numerator of the Medicaid proxy of the Medicare disproportionate share hospital ("DSH") calculation pursuant to 42 U.S.C. Section 1395ww(d)(5...
2014D26
99-1340R
39-0028
Whether pursuant to 42 C.F.R. Section 405.378, or otherwise, and in view of the Intermediary's ten year delay in fully implementing PRRB Decision No. 1998-D26 for PRRB Case No. 91-2673M, interest is due on the underpayments which were otherwise at issue i...
2014D25
09-1897
30-1307
Whether the offset of "investment income" up to the amount of interest expense claimed by the Provider for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2007, was proper.
2014D24
08-0496
19-4650
Was the Intermediary's adjustment to the allocation of the Provider's cost proper?
2014D23
10-0224
16-0030
1. Whether the intermediary and CMS Regional Office for Region VII ("CMS Regional Office") evaluated market share for the provider for the correct geographic area when they denied the provider's request for classification as a sole community hospital on ...
2014D22
06-1304; 07-0199; 08-0025; 08-0231; 08-1852
10-0289
Whether the Intermediary's removal of residents who participated in Colorectal Surgery (fiscal years ("FYs") 2002-2006), Internal Medicient (FYs 2004-2006), and Neurology (FYs 2004-2006) programs (collectively, "Programs") from the Provider's Graduate Med...
2014D21
14-0568
39-1745
Whether the imposition of a two percent reduction in Legacy Hospice and Palliative Care LLC's Medicare payments for calendar year 2014 was proper.
2014D20
07-2549R; 07-2546R; 07-2547R; 07-2548R; 07-2538R; 07-2544R; 07-2532R; 07-2533R and 08-0470R
22-1990; 45-1990; 05-1993 and 05-1991
Whether the training offered by the Providers is necessary to enter the specialty of Christian Science nursing in a Religious, Non-Medical Health Care Institution and therefore, eligible for pass-through reimbursement, or whether the Providers' nurse-trai...
2014D19
09-1065GC and 09-2172G
Various
Whether the Intermediary's disallowance of the Providers' bad debts claims, because the claims had been referred to an outside collection agency, should be reversed because the Intermediary's adjustments violate the Bad Debt Moratorium.
2014D18
04-1350; 05-1139; 06-1473; 06-1477; 04-1348; 05-1185; 06-1353; 06-1303 and 07-1344
15-0132 and 15-0002
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor's disallowance of Methodist Hospital's bad debt claims should be reversed.
2014D17
07-1917G
18-0038; 18-0130; 18-0138; 18-0104; 18-0103; 18-0080
1. Whether the inclusion of surgical technicians, mental health technicians, and heart center recovery technicians in the all-others category instead of the nursing aides, orderlies and attendants category in the Provider's occupational-mix survey was cor...
2014D16
10-0859
16-0214
Whether Wisconsin Physicians Service, the Medicare Administrative Contractor, properly calculated the Medicare dependent hospital volume decrease adjustment for Lakes Regional Healthcare, the Provider, for fiscal year 2006, by improperly excluding certain...
2014D15
10-0386
16-0013
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor improperly calculated the Provider's sole community hospital volume decrease adjustment by excluding certain variable and semi-fixed costs?
2014D14
05-1891; 05-1887; 04-1831; 05-0731 and 06-1938
14-0228
Whether the Temporary Cap Increase Exception applies to the Provider's 1996 base year IME/GME FTE count for osteopathic and allopathic medicine interns and residents and the caps application to the May 31, 1999 through May 31, 2003 FTE counts?
2014D13
08-0611GC; 08-0619GC and 08-0621GC
Various
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments to remove the Medicare bad debts claimed by the Provider while the debts were still at the collection agency were proper?
2014D12
10-1135, 10-1136 and 10-1138
05-0146
Whether the Intermediary properly offset investment income against operating and capital-related interest expense for the fiscal years ending September 30, 2004, September 30, 2005, and September 30 2006?
2014D11
07-0847 and 07-0306
31-0014
1. Whether a provider's collection effort on inpatient and outpatient bad debts must include personal telephone calls to patients to comprise a reasonable collection effort. 2. Whether the Intermediary incorrectly determined that the regulations affirm...
2014D10
06-1337 and 07-1505
20-0033
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) erred by excluding outside rotations from the Provider's Graduate Medical Education (GME) and Indirect Medical Education (IME) full time equivalent (FTE) count?
2014D09
07-2350
51-0086
Was the Intermediary's adjustment to reclassify Rural Health Clinic visits associated with contracted physicians, and the associated full-time equivalents ("FTEs") from cost report Worksheet M-2, line 9 to Worksheet M-2, line 1, correct?
2014D08
07-1797; 08-1631; 11-0211; 11-0596; 11-0609
22-0162
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC)erred in disallowing certain of the costs associated with Dana Farber Cancer Institute (the "Provider") state provider tax expense in the Provider's Fiscal Year 2004 through Fiscal Year 2008 cost reporti...
2014D07
12-0144
31-0031
Whether CMS improperly denied the Provider's request to be reclassified as a rural hospital.
2014D06
07-2006GC
39-5680, 39-5047 and 39-5409
Whether the Intermediary's exclusion of unbilled crossover bad debts was proper.
2014D05
07-2069
39-5110
Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to disallow Medicare Bad Debts on the Medicare Cost Report was proper.
2014D04
11-0010
25-1627
Notice of Effect of Inpatient Day Limitation and Hospice Cap Amount
2014D03
08-2838
07-0033
Whether the Provider Reimbursement Review Board ("Board") has jurisdiction over a claim for Medicaid Eligible Days for which there was no adjustment made by the Intermediary within the Notice of Program Reimbursement.
2014D02
09-1888; 09-1889 and 10-1057GC
01-1600 and 01-1662
Whether the Providers' cap liability for 2006-2008 should be recalculated in light of SouthernCare Hospice's monetary settlement of the qui tam lawsuits filed against it in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Alabama at case numb...
2014D01
06-0615; 06-0651; 06-2373
18-0038
Whether medical assistance/general assistance days associated with patients covered under the Kentucky State Plan should be included in the numerator of the Medicaid proxy of the Medicare disproportionate share hospital ("DSH") calculation pursuant to § ...
2013D42
06-0984
22-0001
Whether the observation bed days for the Provider's fiscal year ending September 30, 2003 ("FY 2003") were properly netted from the calculation of the bed count for purposes of qualifying for a disproportionate share hospital ("DSH") payment, the DSH c...
2013D41
11-0708G; 11-0710GC; 11-0711GC; 11-0712GC; 11-0713GC; 11-0714GC; 11-0716GC; 11-0718GC and 11-0724GC
Various
Whether CMS properly omitted from the Providers' DSH calculation the patient days of individuals who were Supplemental Security Income ("SSI") recipients but who had the amount of their cash payments reduced to zero while they remained in a nursing home?
2013D40
Various
Various
Whether State only eligible (but unpaid) patient days (commonly referred to as General Assistance or GA days), were erroneously excluded from the Medicaid proxy in the Disproportionate Share Hospital (DSH) calculations.
2013D39
02-1590
15-0084
Whether the Provider Reimbursement Review Board ("Board") has jurisdiction over Ambulatory Surgery Costs and Organ Acquisition Costs where the Intermediary made no audit adjustment to the cost report?
2013D38
00-3186G; 04-0361G; 05-0439G; 06-1812G: 08-1845G; 09-1503GC; 09-1581GC; 09-1743GC; 10-0088GC; 10-0129G; 10-0190GC
Various
Should patient days associated with the Medically Indigent and General Assistance/Unemployable Programs in Washington State be included in the numerator of the Medicaid fraction of the Medicare Disproportionate Share Hospital ("DSH") payment calculatio...
2013D37
Various
Various
Whether the Fiscal Intermediaries' adjustments to pension costs for the affected providers resulted in erroneous wage indices for the areas where adjustments were made.
2013D36
09-1573GC
18-0011; 18-0045
Whether days associated with patients covered under the Kentucky Hospital Care Program should be included in the numerator of the Medicaid proxy of the Medicare disproportionate share. hospital ("DSH") calculation pursuant to §1886(d)(5)(F)(vi)(II) of...
2013D35
06-0328
36-0180
Whether the contractor's decision to exclude certain physician Medicare Part A administrative costs under time study codes L and O from the Provider's fiscal year (FY) 2002 wage index data in calculating the FY 2006 wage index should be reversed?
2013D34
07-2753
47-0006
Whether the Provider documented that it experienced in a cost-reporting period compared to the previous cost-reporting period a decrease of more than 5 percent in its total number of patient discharges due to circumstances beyond its control in accorda...
2013D33
12-0409
67-9201
Whether the imposition of a 2 percent reduction in MS Healthcare Center, Inc.'s Medicare payments for calendar year 2012 was proper?
2013D32
12-0408
45-3108
Whether the imposition of a 2 percent reduction in Carinosa Healthcare, Inc.'s Medicare payments for calendar year 2012 was proper?
2013D31
12-0411GC
Various
Whether the imposition of a 2 percent reduction in All Care Home Health, All Care Home Health of San Gabriel, and Comcare Home Health, Inc. Medicare payments for calendar year 2012 was proper.
2013D30
12-0410
49-7593
Whether the imposition of a 2 percent reduction in LivinRite Home Health Services' Medicare payments for calendar year 2012 was proper.
2013D29
12-0251
23-7251
Whether the imposition of a 2 percent reduction in the Medicare payments to the home health agency for calendar year 2012 was proper?
2013D28
12-0208
67-7207
Whether the imposition of a 2 percent reduction in the Medicare payments to the home health agency for calendar year 2012 was proper?
2013D27
12-0180
45-9410
Whether the imposition of a 2 percent reduction in the Medicare payments to the home health agency for calendar year 2012 was proper.
2013D26
12-0407
14-7970
Whether the imposition of a 2 percentage point reduction in the annual market basket percentage update for CMK Home Health Agency, Inc.'s Medicare payments for calendar year 2012 was proper?
2013D25
12-0250
14-7244
Whether the imposition of a 2 percent reduction in the Medicare payments to the home health agency for calendar year 2012 was proper?
2013D24
08-0120G
18-0116; 18-0132
Whether days associated with patients covered under the Kentucky Hospital Care Program ("KHCP") should be included in the numerator of the Medicaid proxy of the Medicare disproportionate share hospital ("DSH") calculation pursuant to§ 1886(d)(5)(F)(vi)(...
2013D23
07-2057G; 07-2058G; 07-2059G; 07-2060G; 07-2061G; 07-2308G and 09-1563G
Various
Whether the Intermediary properly excluded Medicaid eligible Florida Charity Care and Low­ Income days from the disproportionate share hospital ("DSH") calculation.
2013D22
02-1305
39-0097
Whether the Intermediary's adjustment disallowing therapy services claims pursuant to a comprehensive medical review was proper?
2013D21
07-2446G
23-0046
Whether days associated with patients covered under the Michigan Indigent/Charity Care Program should be included in the numerator of the Medicaid proxy of the Medicare disproportionate share hospital ("DSH") calculation pursuant to§ 1886(d)(5)(F)(vi)(...
2013D20
07-0401
32-0085
Whether the Intermediary's determination that the Provider should be reimbursed under the federal rate of the inpatient prospective payment system for capital costs for the fiscal year end 2003 was proper.
2013D19
03-1339
25-0031
Did the Intermediary correctly determine the Provider's disproportionate share hospital ("DSH")payment for the fiscal period November 1, 1998 to June 30, 1999?
2013D18
00-0655G
Various
Whether the methodology of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services for determining the Providers' exception to the hospital-based skilled nursing facility ("HB-SNF") routine cost limit was proper.
2013D17
09-0234
23-2553
Whether CMS' denial of the Provider's request for an exception to the ESRD composite rate was proper?
2013D16
05-1479G
Various
Whether time spent in research when the residents were assigned to the inpatient prospective payment system portion and/or the outpatient department of the Providers should be included in the full-time equivalent counts ("FTE") for indirect medical educat...
2013D15
07-0235
26-0183
Whether the Intermediary used the correct number of days when computing the disproportionate share percentage when the cost-reporting periods overlapped April1, 2004.
2013D14
08-2778
42-0023
Whether the Intermediary's determination not to increase certain Medicare cost outlier payments was proper, where the outliers were underpaid because of an erroneous overpayment of DSH, which was a factor in the outlier amount calculation and which the MA...
2013D13
03-0262,04-1461,05-0450, 06-1449, and 09-0710
31-0119
Whether the Medicare administrative contractor properly determined that the Provider was not entitled to reimbursement for medical education pass-through costs related to the university's nursing education and allied health program because the Provider ...
2013D12
06-0680G
23-0217; 23-0075
Whether the Intermediary appropriately included wage data from Trillium Hospital for purposes of calculating the Federal Fiscal Year 2006 hospital wage index ("FFY 2006 Wage Index") for the Battle Creek, Michigan Metropolitan Statistical Area.
2013D11
10-0236
15-0011
Whether the Medicare Administrative Contractor's (MAC) denial of Marion General Hospital's Sole Community Hospital Low Volume Adjustment was proper based on procedural and timing requirements.
2013D10
07-2274G
Various
Whether days associated with patients covered under the Missouri State Plan should be included in the numerator of the Medicaid proxy of the Medicare disproportionate share hospital (DSH) calculation pursuant to the Social Security Act, as amended (Act).
2013D09
09-0480G, 09-0383G, 09-0491G, 09-0487G, 07-2217G, 07-2291G
Various
Whether the Intermediary's reopening adjustment to exclude Type 6 Medicaid dual eligible days from the Providers' Medicaid fraction used in the calculation of the disproportionate share hospital adjustment was proper.
2013D08
04-0376; 05-01805
36-0009
Whether the Intermediary improperly calculated reimbursement for the Provider's skilled nursing facility unit during the skilled nursing facility PPS (prospective payment system) transition period.
2013D07
Various
Various
Whether the Intermediary improperly eliminated or reduced the pension and postretirement benefit ("PRB") costs of the University of California medical centers ("UC Providers"), and the pension costs of the Catholic Healthcare West medical centers ("CHW Pr...
2013D06
08-0105GC
44-0176; 44-0063
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments to remove Medicare bad debts from the Providers' cost reports were proper?
2013D05
11-0570
20-0050
Was Maine Coast Memorial Hospital's request to be designated as a Sole Community Hospital properly denied?
2013D04
11-0160
10-4993
Whether the Intermediary properly removed total costs and total payments.
2013D03
06-1318; 07-1386
20-0009
Whether the Intermediary's exclusion of the crossover bad debts for cost reporting periods ended September 30, 2002 and September 30, 2003 due to a lack of documentation was proper.
2013D02
06-1735G
16-0067; 28-0013
Whether days associated with patients covered under the Iowa State Plan should be included in the numerator of the Medicaid proxy of the Medicare disproportionate share hospital (DSH) calculation pursuant to § 1886(d)(5)(F)(vi)(II) of the Social Security...
2013D01
07-2447G
39-0009; 39-0147
Whether medical assistance/general assistance days associated with patients covered under the Pennsylvania State Plan should be included in the numerator of the Medicaid proxy of the Medicare disproportionate share hospital (DSH) calculation pursuant to ...
2012D25
10-1237; 10-1236; 10-1235; 12-0034; 12-0033
31-0058
Whether the Provider Reimbursement Review Board ("Board") has jurisdiction over the calculation of the Provider's 1996 Indirect Medical Education ("IME") Cap Reduction for the redistribution of unused residency slots.
2012D24
07-0624; 08-0441; 08-2005; 09-0768
14-0228
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments reducing the 1996 base year IME/GME FTE  count for osteopathic and allopathic medicine interns and residents and their effect on the May 31, 2004 through May 31, 2007 FTE counts are correct.
2012D23
07-2273G
Various
Whether days associated with patients covered under the Colorado Indigent Care Program (CICP) should be included in the numerator of the Medicaid proxy of the Medicare disproportionate share hospital (DSH) calculation pursuant to § 1886(d)(5)(F)(vi)(Il)...
2012D22
08-1580; 10-0178; 10-0179
22-2006
Whether the allocation of the physician costs between Part A and Part B was proper.
2012D21
97-2425R
05-0455
Whether the Secretary's failure to reclassify costs in the peer group construction was arbitrary, capricious or plainly erroneous?
2012D20
08-1417
14-0124
Whether the Intermediary's exclusion of the physician malpractice expense from Worksheets A-8-2 and D-9 of the cost report was proper.
2012D19
02-0387GC
Various
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments to the Laundry and Linen and the Central Service and Supply statistics were proper.
2012D18
08-1404
36-0152
Did the Intermediary properly disallow Medicare bad debt expense- specifically, did the Intermediary correctly disallow those claims from the sample review where the Provider was unable to produce all of the documentation from the patient file used to sub...
2012D17
04-2249G; 10-0431GC; 10-432GC; 10-433GC; 10-434GC; 10-435GC; 10-0436GC; 04-2265G; 10-1206GC; 10-1211GC; 10-1212GC; 10-1213GC; 10-1214GC; 10-1215GC; 10-1216GC; 10-1217GC; 05-1862G; 10-1218GC; 10-1219GC; 10-1220GC; 10-1221GC; 10-1222GC; 10-1223GC; 10-1224GC...
Various
Whether days associated with patients covered under the New Jersey Charity Care Program should be included in the numerator of the Medicaid proxy of the Medicare disproportionate share hospital (DSH) calculation pursuant to § 1886(d)(5)(F)(vi)(II) of th...
2012D16
07-0552; 07-2253
28-0081
Were the Intermediary's adjustments to disallow the Provider's indirect medical education (IME) and direct graduate medical education (DGME) reimbursement for its graduate medical education activities correct?
2012D15
09-0008
19-1555
Whether a full or partial waiver is permissible for the Provider's hospice inpatient day limitation overpayment for the cap year November 1, 2005, through October 31, 2006.
2012D14
09-0704
07-0034
Whether the Provider Reimbursement Review Board has jurisdiction over Medicaid eligible days for which there was no adjustment made by the Intermediary within the Notice of Program Reimbursement.
2012D13
02-0529G
Various
Whether the Fiscal Intermediary and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) appropriately included certain paid hours not actually worked by Parkview Health System (Parkview) employees for purposes of calculating the federal fiscal year 2002 ...
2012D12
06-0269
26-0027
Whether the Intermediary's determination of additional amounts paid to the Provider for nursing and allied health (N&AH) education costs associated with Medicare+ Choice (M+C) enrollees was proper.
2012D11
07-0900; 06-1259; 07-0824; 09-0905; 09-0908; 09-0903; 09-0904
05-0464
Whether the Intermediary improperly eliminated all direct medical education and indirect medical education reimbursement for the Provider's family practice residency program for fiscal years ended May 31, 2001 through May 31, 2007.
2012D10
98-0460
05-0211
Whether the District of Columbia District Court's memorandum decision issued in this case finding the Secretary's methodology was improper under the precedent established in. Alaska Professional Hunters Association, Inc. vs. FAA, 177 F.3d 1030 (D.C. Cir. ...
2012D09
00-2351
14-0119
5-A. Were the Intermediary's adjustments to the Provider's bed count as used for purposes of the indirect medical education (IME) calculation proper?; 5-B. In calculating the Provider's bed count as used for purposes of IME calculation, should there h...
2012D08
96-0819; 97-1814
14-0119
1. Did the Intermediary properly calculate the number of interns and residents for FY 1993 for purposes of the Provider's graduate medical education?; 2-A. Were the Intermediary's adjustments to the Provider's bed count as used for purposes of the indir...
2012D07
06-1709; 05-0627; 06-0192; 06-1710
28-0081
Were the Intermediary's adjustments to disallow the Provider's indirect medical education (IME) and direct graduate medical education (DGME) reimbursement for its graduate medical education activities correct?
2012D06
10-1386GC
Various
Whether inpatient days for Medicaid-eligible patients who were enrolled in a Medicare Choice (M C) plan under Part C of the Medicare statute were properly excluded from the numerator of the Medicaid fraction that is used to calculate the disproportionate ...
2012D05
02-0531G
Various
1. Did the Intermediary err in refusing to exclude Provider's "bonus" or "call back" hours paid from its Federal Fiscal Year (FFY) 2002 wage index calculations?; 2. Did the Intermediary err in refusing to include salary costs for Provider's Senior Vice Pr...
2012D04
09-0894; 08-1351; 09-0892
23-0142
Did the Oakwood Annapolis Family Practice Residency Program, which received "provisional accreditation" from the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) meet the definition of a "new" program in 2004.
2012D03
09-0957
23-0021
Whether the Intermediary's disallowance of Medicare bad debts that had been referred to an outside collection agency was proper.
2012D02
08-2202; 08-2203
25-0117
1. Whether CMS is precluded from recovering the alleged overpayments from the Provider's fiscal year end 12/31/97 and 10/31/98 cost reports due to the Intermediary's issuance of the Notice of Program Reimbursement over ten years after the cost report year...
2012D01
Various
Various
1. Whether the Fiscal Intermediary and CMS properly determined the Wage Indexes for St. Elizabeth Medical Center (18-0035); St. Luke Hospital East (18-0001); St. Luke Hospital West (18-0045); Mercy Hospital Anderson (36-0001); University Hospital, Inc. (3...
2011D47
09-2261CG
23-0024; 23-0104; 23-0273; 23-0277
Whether the Intermediary properly disallowed the Providers' pension costs for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2006 in determining the Medicare geographical wage index for federal fiscal year (FFY) 2010.
2011D46
08-1452; 08-1800; 08-2699; 08-2533; 08-2534; 08-1156; 08-2532; 09-0914
Various
1. Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to the direct graduate medical education and indirect medical education counts for residents training at the Kalamazoo Center for Medical Studies/Michigan State University nonhospital site clinics was proper.; 2. W...
2011D45
05-1802
39-3050
Whether the Intermediary properly reimbursed the Provider based on the blended rate for inpatient rehabilitation facilities (IRF) versus the 100 percent federal prospective payment system (PPS) rate for IRFs.
2011D44
05-1144
33-0201
Whether the Provider's cost reimbursement should be computed taking into account the charges included in the Provider's log of late charges which have not been billed to Medicare.
2011D43
05-0023
33-0201
Whether the Provider's cost reimbursement should be computed taking into account the charges included in the Provider's log of late charges which have not been billed to Medicare.
2011D42
98-2219; 98-2218; 01-2534; 03-1358
45-0610
Does the Board have jurisdiction over the issue of whether the Provider is entitled to be reimbursed for the interest implicit in the capital lease of the hospital facilities and equipment?
2011D41
04-1753G; 04-1824G; 04-1825G; 05-0375G; 05-1794G; 06-1093G; 07-0888GC; 09-2062GC; 10-0941GC; et al
Various
Whether Medicare+Choice (M+C) days should be included in the Medicaid fraction used to calculate the disproportionate share hospital (DSH) adjustment.
2011D40
10-0069GC
Various
Whether inpatient days for Medicaid-eligible patients who were enrolled in a Medicare Choice (M C) plan under Part C of the Medicare statute were properly excluded from the numerator of the Medicaid fraction that is used to calculate the disproportionate ...
2011D39
09-0206GC
Various
Whether inpatient days for Medicaid-eligible patients who were enrolled in a Medicare Choice (M C) plan under Part C of the Medicare statute were properly excluded from the numerator of the Medicaid fraction that is used to calculate the disproportionate ...
2011D38
07-0522
50-1312
Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to the Provider's ambulance service rates was proper.
2011D37
06-0867GC; 08-2122GC; 08-1592GC
Various
Should patient days attributable to Medicare beneficiaries who elected to enroll in a Medicare+Choice (M+C) plan be included in the numerator of the Medicaid fraction that was used to calculate each of the Providers' Disproportionate Share Hospital (DSH) ...
2011D36
06-1431; 06-2384
40-0110
Whether the Intermediary improperly excluded certain days attributable to Puerto Rico Medicaid enrollees who were classified by the Administration De Seguros De Salute De Puerto Rico as category six, for which Puerto Rico receives no Federal matching fund...
2011D35
09-1970
14-0094
Whether CMS properly reduced the Provider's Outpatient Prospective Payment System (OPPS) Calendar Year (CY) 2009 market basket update by two (2.0) percentage points.
2011D34
05-1740G
Various
Whether the Intermediary improperly disallowed direct graduate medical education (DGME) and indirect medical education (IME) payments related to managed care days, discharges, and simulated payments solely on the grounds the provider failed to submit UB 9...
2011D33
08-1168; 08-1169; 08-1170; 08-1171; 09-0911; 09-0130; 09-1195
19-0090
Whether the Provider is eligible to be classified and reimbursed as a Medicare Dependent Hospital (MDH) for the fiscal years ended (FYEs) 2/31/01, 12/31/02, 12/31/03, 12/31/04, 12/31/05, 03/31/07, and 03/31/08.
2011D32
06-2319
06-0009
Whether the Intermediary properly disallowed the Provider's entire Medicare disproportionate share hospital (DSH) payment.
2011D31
04-0848
09-0001
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments of the Provider's bad debts, because they were written off while they remained at an outside collection agency, were appropriate.
2011D30
07-0084GC
Various
Whether the Fiscal Intermediary improperly disallowed the Provider's claimed Medicare bad debts solely on the ground that accounts related to such bad debts were still pending at outside collection agencies.
2011D29
05-0148
31-0091
Whether the Intermediary properly included all appropriate Medicaid eligible days in calculating the Provider's disproportionate patient percentage for purposes of the Medicare disproportionate share hospital (DSH) adjustment under the Prospective Payment...
2011D28
08-2579
05-0126
Did CMS properly reduce the Provider's federal fiscal year (FFY) 2008 inpatient prospective payments system market basket adjust by two (2.0) percentage points?
2011D27
08-1474
33-0005
1. Whether the Intermediary's adjustment of the Provider's direct Graduate Medical Education per resident amount was proper.; 2. Whether the Intermediary properly excluded research time the Provider alleges was related to patient care from the Full Time E...
2011D26
08-0384
19-1555
Whether a full or partial waiver is permissible for the Provider's hospice inpatient day limitation overpayment for the cap year November 1, 2004 through October 31, 2005.
2011D25
00-2803
52-0174
Whether the Provider's post-retirement health benefit costs are allowable costs in the Provider's terminating cost report under Provider Reimbursement Manual (PRM) Section2176.
2011D24
03-1199G
17-0040; 17-0086; 17-0122
Whether the Intermediary should include all MediKan patient days, primary and secondary, in the Providers' disproportionate share hospital (DSH) calculation.
2011D23
05-0476
45-0068
Whether the Intermediary properly disallowed the loss claimed by Hermann Hospital representing a complete write-off of the book value of its depreciable assets as a result of the merger with the Memorial Hospital System.
2011D22
04-0661; 04-0663
45-0705
Whether the Provider is entitled to payment of "fair compensation" pursuant to 42 C.F.R. Section 413.13.
2011D21
04-0327; 04-0328
45-0728
Whether the Provider is entitled to payment of "fair compensation" pursuant to 42 C.F.R.Section 413.13.
2011D20
08-2752GC; 04-2131G; 04-2132G; 04-2133G; 04-2134G; 08-2845GC; 08-2756GC
Various
Whether for fiscal years 1995-1998 the Intermediary should include dual-eligible, Medicare health maintenance organization (HMO) patient days in the Medicaid proxy in determining Medicare reimbursement for disproportionate share hospital (DSH) payments in...
2011D19
09-0003GC; 04-2135G; 04-2136G; 04-2137G; 06-1907G; 06-1906G; 08-2753GC; 08-2757GC; 08-2847GC
Various
Whether the Intermediary should include dual-eligible, Medicare + Choice (M + C) patient days in the numerator of the Medicaid proxy in determining Medicare reimbursement for disproportionate share hospital (DSH) payments in accordance with the Medicare s...
2011D18
05-1032; 06-1173
09-0001
Whether the Intermediary properly extrapolated the sample error rate to the population in adjusting Medicaid eligible days.
2011D17
05-1761
51-0022
Whether the provider has a right to a hearing on certain graduate medical education costs and kidney acquisition costs that were not claimed on the cost report.
2011D16
09-1058
33-0094
Was CMS' determination to reduce the Provider's inpatient prospective payment system market basket update for federal fiscal year (FY) 2009 by two (2.0) percentage points proper?
2011D15
09-1796
05-0018
Whether the Provider is entitled to the full market basket update for Federal Fiscal Year ending 2009 under the Reporting Hospital Quality Data for Annual Payment Update Program.
2011D14
06-1927G; 08-0138G; 09-1545GC
Various
Whether the Intermediary properly excluded Connecticut's State-Administered General Assistance (SAGA) program days from the Medicare disproportionate share hospital (DSH) calculation for fiscal year-ends (FYEs) September 30, 2001 through September 30, 200...
2011D13
08-1695
05-0746
Whether it was proper for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Service to reduce by two percent the Medicare annual payment update for Western Medical Center - Santa Ana for federal fiscal year 2008.
2011D12
06-2376; 06-2377; 06-2378; 06-2379; 06-2381; 06-2383; 06-2385; 06-2410
Various
Whether the Fiscal Intermediary properly adjusted the Providers' bad debts for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2004.
2011D11
06-2033
01-0164
Whether the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), reversal of the Provider's rural referral center (RRC) classification was proper.
2011D10
00-3532G; 04-1657G; 06-0468G; 07-2031G; 08-2585G
Various
Whether the Intermediary's non-inclusion of the Indiana Hospital Care for the Indigent (HCI) program patient days as Medicaid eligible days, whether paid or unpaid, in the calculation of the Medicaid proxy for Medicare Disproportionate Share Hospital (DSH...
2011D09
08-2162GC; 08-2165GC; 08-2186G; 08-2233GC et al
Various
Whether the Intermediary properly excluded the Ohio Hospital Care Assurance Program (HCAP) days from the Medicare disproportionate share hospital (DSH) calculation.
2011D08
09-1927
37-1633
1. Has the Provider demonstrated that it is entitled to a hearing before the Board because there is at least $10,000 in controversy?; 2. To what extent, if at all, Medicare's $397,228 demand for repayment from the Provider for fiscal year 2007, calculated...
2011D07
00-1489
05-0107
Whether a loss on disposal of assets is required to be recognized by Medicare as a result of the April 24, 1997 statutory merger of the Provider.
2011D06
05-0508G; 06-0784G; 07-0510G; 08-1412G
Various
Whether the Intermediary/Medicare Administrative Contractor properly calculated the Providers' 1996 resident cap for purposes of direct graduate medical education and indirect graduate medical education payments.
2011D05
05-2270
19-7717
Whether the Provider Statistical and Reimbursement Reports (PS&Rs) used to settle the Provider's cost reports for the fiscal years ended May 31, 1998 and March 17, 1999 are accurate.
2011D04
06-0828
05-0090
Whether the Intermediary's reclassification of clinic meals statistics on Worksheet B-1 from the reimbursable "clinic" cost center (clinic) to a non-reimbursable cost center was proper.
2011D03
08-0298G
Various
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments to the Providers' Medicare bad debts were proper.
2011D02
06-1009; 07-0237
06-0031
Whether the Intermediary improperly recouped alleged overpayments resulting from an incorrect cost-to-charge ratio (CCR) calculated and applied by the Intermediary to determine outlier payments made to the Provider for inpatient rehabilitation services fu...
2011D01
06-0419G; 06-1433G; 06-1482G; 06-1451G; 07-0020G
Various
Whether the Intermediary has improperly adjusted the Providers' direct graduate medical education (GME) intern and resident full-time equivalent (FTE) counts for their respective fiscal years ended (FYE) 12/31/1999 through 12/31/2003 by disallowing variou...
2010D53
05-1261
23-0053
1. Whether the Intermediary properly determined the Provider's full time equivalents (FTEs) counts used for purposes of calculating payment for direct graduate medical education (DGME) and indirect medical education (IME), based on its exclusion of reside...
2010D52
Various
Various
Whether Medicare Choice (M C) days should be included in the Medicaid fraction used to calculate the disproportionate share hospital (DSH) adjustment.
2010D51
04-2159
18-0141
Whether the Intermediary improperly reduced the Provider's numbers of resident full-time equivalents ("FTEs") used for purposes of Medicare direct graduate medical education ("GME") and indirect graduate medical education ("IME") based on its contention t...
2010D50
06-1889; 06-1886; 06-1890; 02-1517; 06-1888; 06-1887; 06-0755; 06-0524; 06-1142
03-0061
1. Whether the Provider's nursing education program qualified as provider-operated.; 2. Whether, assuming the Provider's nursing education program did not qualify as provider-operated, the Provider is entitled to receive an additional payment to account f...
2010D49
10-0056
37-1635
Whether the amount in controversy requirement under 42 C.F.R. Section 405.1835 is satisfied.
2010D48
Various
Various
Should the ProviderReimbursement Review Board grant the Provider's request for expedited judicial review (EJR) over the validity of the provisions of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Ruling CMS-1498-R, which if valid, render moot and deny juri...
2010D47
08-2017
14-0132
Whether the Provider Reimbursement Review Board has jurisdiction over Medicaid eligible days that were not specifically considered within the implementation of a revised Notice of Program Reimbursement (NPR).
2010D46
97-0206
05-0008
Whether the Intermediary properly denied the Provider's Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act (TEFRA) exception request because of the timeliness of the request.
2010D45
04-0380; 05-1209; 06-0688
03-0064
1. Whether the Intermediary properly excluded resident rotations for research and other scholarly activities when calculating the resident full time equivalent (FTE) count for indirect medical education (IME) adjustment purposes.; 2. Whether the Intermedi...
2010D44
04-2270; 07-0278; 07-1351; 08-0169
37-0202
Whether the hospital as a new provider is entitled to capital hold-harmless methodology under the prospective payment system beyond the 10-year transition period.
2010D43
02-0162
10-5990
In light of the August 29, 2007 Remand Order from the Administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services ("CMS"), what is the proper regulation and manual provision to apply to the facts of this case and what is the relevance of the Provider'...
2010D42
98-1025
23-0029
1. Whether the Medicare bad debt payment was computed properly.; 2. Whether the Medicaid Proxy component of the disproportionate share hospital (DSH) adjustment was computed properly.; 3. Whether the Medicare Proxy component of the disproportionate share ...
2010D41
04-0495G
Various
Whether the Intermediary erred in excluding certain contract labor costs, home office costs, and wage-related costs that were claimed by Bon Secours-DePaul Medical Center, Maryview Medical Center, and Mary Immaculate Hospital (collectively, the "Bon Seco...
2010D40
01-1346G
Various
Whether the Intermediary's calculation of the Providers' Medicare disproportionate share hospital ("DSH") payments improperly excluded "expansion waiver" days attributable to patients who received medical assistance through Tennessee's Medicaid demonstrat...
2010D39
10-0081
46-0003
Should the Provider Reimbursement Review Board ("Board") grant the Providers' request for expedited judicial review ("EJR") over the validity of the provisions of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Ruling CMS-1498-R, which if valid, render moo...
2010D38
10-0165G; 10-0162GC; and 10-0169GC
Various
1. Should the Provider Reimbursement Review Board ("Board") grant the Providers' request for expedited judicial review ("EJR") over the question of whether Medicare Part C days should be excluded from the numerator and denominator of the Supplemental Sec...
2010D37
02-0816
22-5681
Was the Intermediary's denial of the Provider's request for a new provider exemption from Medicare routine service cost limits proper in light of the standards set forth in St. Elizabeth's Medical Center of Boston, Inc. v. Thompson, 396 Fed. 3rd 1228 (D.C...
2010D36
07-2626G; 06-2111GC; 09-2298GC
Various
Should the Provider Reimbursement Review Board grant the Providers' request for expedited judicial review (EJR) over the validity of the provisions of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Ruling CMS-1498-R, which if valid, render moot and deny jur...
2010D35
98-0850G; 09-1633GC; 09-1634GC; 09-1635GC; 07-2034G; 07-2032G; 07-2033G
Various
Whether the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services' methodology for determining the exception from the routine cost limits (RCL) for hospital-based skilled nursing facilities (HB-SNF) was proper.
2010D34
08-0382; 08-0383
19-1555
Whether the Intermediary followed the proper reopening procedures prior to the issuance of the Intermediary's letter dated June 11, 2007 (Notice of Effect of Inpatient Day Limitation and Hospice Cap Amount) recalculating the hospice cap for years ending O...
2010D33
05-0171G; 05-0172G; 05-0173G; 06-0153G; 07-0453G; 08-1308G; 09-0964GC
Various
Whether days for which patients received charity care in Pennsylvania were required by the Medicare statute to be included in the numerator of the Medicaid proxy of the Medicare DSH calculation.
2010D32
05-1693; 05-1694
36-0175
Was the Intermediary's adjustment to include outpatient observation bed days in the bed count for purposes of calculating the Provider's indirect medical education (IME) reimbursement proper?
2010D31
09-0072
11-0034
Whether the Board has jurisdiction over the Provider's appeal of whether the disproportionate share (DSH) adjustment was incorrectly determined due to a significant error in the Supplemental Security Income (SSI) percentage where the appeal was not filed ...
2010D30
09-0071
11-0034
Whether the Board has jurisdiction over the Provider's appeal of the question of whether the disproportionate share (DSH) adjustment was incorrectly determined due to a significant error in the Supplemental Security Income (SSI) percentage where the reque...
2010D29
08-1848; 09-1547; 10-0106; 06-1773; 07-2384; 08-2266; 09-1565
10-1406; 10-1416
Was the Intermediary's adjustment disallowing bad debts arising from coinsurance and deductibles for dual eligible Medicare and Medicaid beneficiaries proper?
2010D28
05-0289
33-0224
Whether the Intermediary properly adjusted the Provider's Family Practice residency program direct graduate medical education (DGME) and indirect medical education (IME) full-time equivalent (FTE) count for the fiscal year ended December 31, 2000.
2010D27
04-0114G; 05-0286G; 06-0943G; 06-1377G; 07-0311G; 04-0940
Various
Whether the Intermediary underpaid the Providers' fiscal years 2000 through 2004 Medicare operating and capital disproportionate share hospital (DSH) adjustments by not including the Providers' New Jersey Charity Care Program (NJCCP) inpatient days in the...
2010D26
05-1790G
Various
Should patient days associated with Medicare Part A and Title XIX eligible patients that were not included in the Supplemental Security Income (SSI) percentage factor of the Medicare disproportionate share formula be included in the Medicaid days factor o...
2010D25
08-0251G
Various
Whether the CMS must-bill policy applies to the Providers' dual-eligible bad debts when the Providers did not participate in the Medicaid program.
2010D24
01-2257
12-0001
Whether First Coast Service Options, Inc. (Intermediary) improperly excluded patient days associated with patients who were dually eligible for both the Medicare and Medicaid programs but for such days there was no Medicare Part A payment or coverage avai...
2010D23
07- 0459; 07-2370
03-5143
Whether the CMS must-bill policy applies to the Provider's dual-eligible bad debts when the Provider did not participate in the Medicaid program.
2010D22
04-2157; 05-0706
39-0204; 39-0022
Whether General Assistance (GA) days should be added to the numerator of the "Medicaid" proxy in the Disproportionate Share (DSH) payment calculation.
2010D21
07-2829
10-1472
Was the Intermediary's adjustment disallowing bad debts arising from coinsurance and deductibles for dual eligible Medicare and Medicaid beneficiaries proper?
2010D20
00-4034G; 00-4035G; 00-4036G; 05-0157G
Various
Whether the Providers have been properly paid for bad debts for Medicare deductible and coinsurance amounts associated with Medicaid eligible inpatients for services between May 1, 1994 and June 30, 1998.
2010D19
07-2538; 07-2544
45-1990
Whether the Fiscal Intermediary's denial of the Provider's nursing education program costs as pass-through costs was valid when that denial was based on a finding that the Commission for the Accreditation of Christian Science Nursing Organization/Faciliti...
2010D18
07-2532
05-1993
Whether the Fiscal Intermediary's denial of the Provider's nursing education program costs as pass-through costs was valid when that denial was based on a finding that the Commission for the Accreditation of Christian Science Nursing Organization/Faciliti...
2010D17
07-2533; 08-0470
05-1991
Whether the Fiscal Intermediary's denial of the Provider's nursing education program costs as pass-through costs was valid when that denial was based on a finding that the Commission for the Accreditation of Christian Science Nursing Organization/Faciliti...
2010D16
07-2546; 07-2547; 07-2548; 07-2549
22-1990
Whether the Fiscal Intermediary's denial of the Provider's nursing education program costs as pass-through costs was valid when that denial was based on a finding that the Commission for the Accreditation of Christian Science Nursing Organization/Faciliti...
2010D15
08-1816
36-0151
Does the Board have jurisdiction over the resident-to-bed ratio where an alleged error in the filed cost report was discovered by the Provider after the final determination was issued?
2010D14
05-0828
10-0061
Whether the provider has a right to hearing on correction of its cost report to reclassify certain nurse expenses.
2010D13
06-1800
10-1440
Was the Intermediary's adjustment disallowing bad debts arising from coinsurance and deductibles for dual eligible Medicare and Medicaid beneficiaries proper?
2010D12
06-2136G; 07-2590G;08-2765GC;082961GC;08-2963GC; 08-2964GC
Various
Whether the Intermediary's disallowance of the Illinois provider tax assessment was proper.
2010D11
04-0228G
Various
Whether the various Intermediaries properly disallowed reimbursement to the Providers for uncollected coinsurance and deductible amounts relating to outpatient therapy services claimed as bad debt during the Providers' respective cost-reporting years endi...
2010D10
98-3417G
Various
Whether the Intermediary's deletion of therapy costs from line 25, column 9 of Worksheet B-1 of the Providers' Medicare cost reports is proper and in accordance with Medicare cost reporting practices and procedures.
2010D09
00-3325
05-0146; 05-7037
Whether the Provider timely filed its Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act (TEFRA) exception request.
2010D08
08-2068
37-1633
1. Has the Provider demonstrated that it is entitled to a hearing before the Board because there is $10,000 in controversy?; 2. To what extent, if at all, Medicare's $720,991 demand for repayment from the Provider for fiscal year 2006 would be decreased i...
2010D07
06-0301; 06-0302
16-0083
Whether the Intermediary improperly calculated the Provider's Medicare disproportionate share hospital (DSH) payment by excluding patient days attributable to hospital inpatients who were eligible for Medicaid and enrolled in Medicare Part A for all or a ...
2010D06
08-0429
42-0078
Whether the intermediary's disallowance of resident time spent in didactic activities for purposes of the indirect medical education adjustment was proper.
2010D05
03-0859G; 04-1027G; 05-1256G
Various
Whether Intermediary properly excluded New Jersey Charity Care Program (NJCCP) days from the Medicare disproportionate share (DSH) calculation for fiscal year-ends (FYEs) 2000 to 2002 for the hospitals in this group appeal.
2010D04
05-0917; 05-0916
26-4020
Whether the Intermediary properly declined to establish a per-resident amount (PRA) and full-time equivalent (FTE) cap applicable to Provider's graduate medical education (GME) costs.
2010D03
07-0793G
Various
Did the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) err in calculating a budget neutrality adjustment to the PPS standardized amount to account for the effect of the rural floor on the wage index?
2010D02
06-1078G; 06-1079G
Various
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments to the Provider's reimbursable capital costs after denying "new hospital" status was proper.
2010D01
01-2484
06-0024
Whether the Intermediary's determination that the resident time was not spent in the hospital complex was proper and with respect to some residents, the resident time was adequately documented as occurring in the contested area.
2009D42
Various
26-2011; 26-2010
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments treating the Management Services Corporation (MSC) pool payments the Providers received as provider refunds, which were offset against the allowable provider tax expense, were proper.
2009D41
05-0350; 06-0452
33-0004
Whether the intermediary properly adjusted the Provider's direct graduate medical education (DGME) and indirect medical education (IME) full-time equivalent (FTE) count for the fiscal years ended December 31, 2000 and December 31, 2001.
2009D40
05-1291; 05-1292; 05-1293
10-4504; 10-4561; 10-4560
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments reflected in the revised Notices of Program Reimbursement (NPR), that reduced allowable home office costs, were proper.
2009D39
04-1799G
Various
Whether inpatient hospital days attributable to individuals who applied to the Providers for, and received, assistance under Georgia's Indigent Care Trust Fund ("ICTF") should be counted in the number of Medicaid-eligible days in the numerator of the Medi...
2009D38
06-0316G; 06-0317G; 06-0318G; 06-0319G
Various
Whether the Intermediary improperly computed the numerator of the Medicaid fractions that were used to calculate the Provider's disproportionate share hospital (DSH) payments for fiscal years 1999, 2000, 2001, and 2002 by excluding inpatient days attribut...
2009D37
98-3491
39-0160; 39-5580
Whether the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services' methodology for determining the Provider's exception to the hospital-based skill nursing facility (HB-SNF) routine cost limit was proper.
2009D36
06-1080G; 06-1081G
Various
Whether the Intermediary"s adjustments to the Provider's reimbursable capital cost after denying "new hospital" status was proper.
2009D35
04-2261G
Various
Whether the Intermediary's calculation of the Provider's Medicare disproportionate share hospital (DSH) payments improperly omitted days attributable to patients who were dually eligible for Medicare Part A and Medicaid, but for which Medicare Part A did ...
2009D34
99-1786; 99-2499; 00-2047; 01-1820
22-0042; 22-5699
1. Whether the Intermediary's audit adjustment disallowing the entire loss on the disposition of assets claimed by the Provider, when the Provider corporation merged with another provider corporation, were appropriate.; 2. Whether the Intermediary properl...
2009D33
06-0814
45-0296
Whether the Intermediary's adjustment of the disproportionate share hospital (DSH) reimbursement, based on its determination that the Provider had less than 100 available beds for DSH eligibility purposes, was proper.
2009D32
05-1133; 06-0127
05-0234
1. Whether the Intermediary's calculation of the Provider's disproportionate share hospital (DSH) payments, as it pertains to subacute unit days was proper.; 2. Whether the Intermediary's calculation of the Provider's disproportionate share hospital (DSH)...
2009D31
05-2010
45-0299
Whether the Intermediary's adjustment of Disproportionate Share Hospital (DSH) reimbursement, based on its determination that the Provider had less than 100 available beds for DSH eligibility purposes, was proper.
2009D30
04-2128G
Various
Whether the exclusion of patient days attributable to Medicare Choice (M C) enrollees from the Medicaid fraction in calculating the Providers' disproportionate patient percentages contravenes the statute and regulations.
2009D29
98-0892
17-0122
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments disallowing a loss claimed by St. Francis Regional Medical Center upon its consolidation with St. Joseph Medical Center to form Via Christi Regional Medical Center was proper.
2009D28
04-0597G; 05-0663G; 06-0682G; 03-0282G; 04-0598G
Various
Whether paid lunch period time should be added to hours used to calculate the Providers' hourly wage rates.
2009D27
05-1370
52-0051
Whether the Medicare statute requires the Provider's Long Term Respiratory Unit (LTRU) days to be excluded from the Medicaid Proxy of the Medicare DSH calculation under 42 U.S.C. Section 1395ww(d)(5)(F)(vi)(II).
2009D26
Various
Various
Whether the Intermediary properly excluded dual eligible patient days from the Medicaid eligible days in determining the Medicaid percentages that were used for the disproportionate share hospital (DSH) adjustment payments.
2009D25
00-3473G
Various
Whether the Intermediary properly excluded Connecticut's State-Administered General assistance (SAGA) program days from the Medicare disproportionate share hospital (DSH) calculation for fiscal year-ends (FYEs) 1994 to 1998 for hospitals in this group app...
2009D24
99-2786
22-0118
Whether the Intermediary's disallowance of the Provider's claim for a loss in connection with its October 1, 1996 statutory merger was proper.
2009D23
99-0584R (on Remand)
39-0080
Whether the Jeanes Hospital merger was a bona fide sale.
2009D22
99-1340
39-0028
Whether interest is due on the continuing underpayments that exist as a result of the fiscal Intermediary's 10 year delay in implementing the PRRB's case number 91-2673.
2009D21
09-0380GC
Various
Whether the Board has jurisdiction over a challenge to an overpayment recoupment action involving the Provider's liability for erroneous payments made to the former owners of the skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) after the change of ownership.
2009D20
04-1997G
Various
Whether the Intermediary improperly disallowed direct graduate medical education (DGME) and indirect medical education (IME) payments with respect to discharges of Medicare beneficiaries who were enrolled in Medicare+Choice or other Medicare risk plans in...
2009D19
05-1873; 05-1879; 05-1880; 05-1881
24-0036
Whether the Intermediary should have included all general assistance days in the computation of the Provider's Medicare Disproportionate Share (DSH) adjustment calculation for the Provider's fiscal years ended June 30, 1997, 1998, 1999, and 2000.
2009D18
09-0801 thru 09-0810; 09-0815; 09-0816
05-0126
Whether the Board has jurisdiction over the Intermediary's refusal to reopen cost reports to adjust the Supplemental Security Income percentages where the request for reopening were filed more than three years after the issuance of the Notices of Program ...
2009D17
09-0764G; 09-1053GC
Various
Should the Provider Reimbursement Review Board (Board) grant expedited judicial review over the question of whether Secretary's elimination of the budget neutrality adjustment factor (BNAF) used in the calculation of hospice payment rates was proper?
2009D16
05-1296G; 05-1315G; 05-2197G; 06-1668G
07-0010; 07-0022; 07-0018
Whether the Intermediary properly disallowed direct graduate medical education (DGME) and indirect medical education (IME) payments with respect to discharges of Medicare beneficiaries who were enrolled in the Medicare + Choce or other Medicare risk plans...
2009D15
92-1212; 92-1522
45-0196
Whether the denial of the Provider's request for an exception to the Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act (TEFRA) rate for its rehabilitation unit was proper.
2009D14
04-1293
08-5029
1. Whether the Intermediary's notification of the reopening of the Provider's 1996 cost report was timely pursuant to regulatory standards.; 2. Whether the Intermediary's determination to disallow costs for the Provider's contracted therapy services was p...
2009D13
02-0488; 03-1001
05-4144
Whether the Intermediary's determination of the Provider's direct graduate medical education (DGME) payment was proper.
2009D12
08-2907G
Various
Whether the Board has jurisdiction over a challenge to the validity of the Supplemental Security Income percentage under the doctrine of equitable tolling where the appeals were not filed within three years of the issuance of Providers' Notices of Program...
2009D11
05-1360G; 05-1362G; 05-1363G; 05-1527G
Various
Whether the Intermediary improperly disallowed from the calculation of the Providers' Disproportionate Share Hospital (DSH) payments, patient days associated with Medicaid patients who were admitted to the hospital prior to the day of giving birth and tha...
2009D10
07-1969G
19-5350; 11-5612; 15-5473; 11-5535
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments to disallow Medicare bad debts written off by Kindred Healthcare and claimed as worthless after the year end date of the terminating cost report it filed for each skilled nursing facility, due to change of ownership,...
2009D09
07-1153
27-1325
Whether the Intermediary's disallowance of the Provider's certified registered nurse anesthetist (CRNA) on-call costs was proper.
2009D08
98-3176G
05-0008; 05-0058; 05-0132; 05-0152; 05-0655
Whether the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services' (CMS) methodology for determining the Providers' exception to the hospital-based skilled nursing facility cost limits was proper.
2009D07
05-1420G
Various
Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to utilization review costs was proper.
2009D06
04-1790G
03-0002; 03-0065; 03-0018
Whether the Intermediary improperly omitted certain inpatient hospital days from the numerator of the Medicaid low-income proxy used to calculate the Providers' disproportionate share hospital (DSH) adjustment.
2009D05
06-1300; 06-1301; 06-1307
03-0103
Whether the Intermediary used proper cost to charge ratios in calculating the Provider's outlier payments.
2009D04
04-1915
03-0023
Whether the Intermediary properly calculated and applied the Provider's ambulance cost per trip limit.
2009D03
04-2130G
50-0024
Whether the Intermediary should include dual-eligible, managed care days in the Medicaid proxy in determining Medicare reimbursement for disproportionate share hospital (DSH) payments in accordance with the Medicare statute at 42 U.S.C. Section 1395ww(d)(...
2009D02
04-0596G
Various
Whether the intermediary properly determined the Rochester New York Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA) wage index for fiscal year 2004 in a manner that reflected the relative hospital wage level in that geographic area as compared to the national average...
2009D01
96-1627G
39-0001
Whether the Medicaid percentage component of the Provider's disproportionate share hospital (DSH) adjustment has been properly computed to contain all Medicaid patient days including Medicaid eligible days.
2008D45
05-1891; 05-1887; 04-1831; 05-0731; 06-1938
14-0228
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments reducing the 1996 base year IME/GME FTE count for osteopathic and allopathic medicine interns and residents and their effect on the May 31, 1999 through May 31, 2003 FTE counts are correct.
2008D44
03-1643
37-0190
Whether the Intermediary properly treated the Provider as an acute care prospective payment system (PPS) facility instead of an excluded cancer hospital.
2008D43
04-1792; 05-2073; 05-2074; 05-2154; 06-0010; 06-0300
37-0078
Whether the Intermediary properly adjusted the Provider's indirect medical education full-time equivalent (FTE) cap?
2008D42
04-0393G
23-0412; 23-0270; 23-0176
Whether as a result of underpayment of Medicare reimbursement during the ten-year transition period of the Capital Prospective Payment System (CPPS), the Providers are entitled to a payment of interest under the Medicare statute, 42 U.S.C. Section 1395g(d...
2008D41
06-0614
23-0097
Whether the Intermediary correctly limited the Provider's ambulance reimbursement to its charges.
2008D40
06-0987
27-1328
Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to Certified Registered Nurse Anesthetist (CRNA) cost was proper.
2008D39
00-1456
39-0098
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments disallowing the loss on disposal of depreciable assets through consolidation were proper.
2008D38
00-1454
39-0067
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments disallowing the loss on disposal of depreciable assets through consolidation were proper.
2008D37
04-1083; 04-1091; 04-1093; 04-1950
22-0033
1. Whether the Intermediary improperly computed the numerator of the Medicaid fractions that were used to calculate the Provider's disproportionate share hospital (DSH) payments for fiscal years (FYs) 1999, 2000, 2001, and 2002 by excluding inpatient days...
2008D36
99-3519M
05-0625
Whether the Intermediary may refuse to apply a revised graduate medical education base year average per resident amount to the subsequent cost years that fall outside the three-year reopening period set forth in 42 C.F.R. Section 405.1885.
2008D35
05-2054
36-0112
1. Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to include outpatient observation bed days in the bed count for purposes of calculating the Provider's indirect medical education (IME) reimbursment was proper.; 2. Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to in...
2008D34
02-1010; 02-0892; 02-1663; 02-2148; 30-0597; 03-1011; 04-0021; 04-0022
23-0053
1. Whether the Intermediary properly excluded FTEs attributable to rotations by residents in certain unaccredited training programs.; 2. Whether the Intermediary properly excluded IME FTEs attributable to time spent by residents in research that was requi...
2008D33
98-0019; 02-0785
22-5682
1. Whether the Provider is entitled to a new provider exemption from the skilled nursing facility (SNF) routine service cost limits under 42 C.F.R. section 1413.30(e) for the cost reporting year ended December 31, 1995.; 2. Whether the Intermediary's deni...
2008D32
03-0778; 04-0914
23-0216
1. Whether the Provider was required to submit a claim to the Michigan Medicaid program and to obtain a Medicaid remittance advice in order to receive Medicare reimbursement for Part B bad debts relating to services furnished to patients dually eligible f...
2008D31
02-0705
05-0241
Whether the Intermediary may recoup an overpayment relative to the Provider's 1987 cost reporting period through a revised Notice of Program Reimbursement (NPR) issued in January 2002.
2008D30
02-0050; 02-0615
14-4036
1. Whether the Intermediary properly adjusted Medicare bad debts.; 2. Whether the Intermediary properly adjusted the Provider's treatment of asset relifing.; 3. Whether the Intermediary properly adjusted public relations and marketing expenses.; 4. Whethe...
2008D29
05-0133G; 05-243G
Various
Was the Provider's reimbursement for indirect medical education (IME) and direct graduate medical education (DGME) for Medicare managed care patients properly disallowed for fiscal year 1999 and fiscal year 2000 for failure to file UB92s in accordance wit...
2008D28
02-0463
03-7205
Whether the Intermediary properly reclassified professional fees from the Administrative and General (A and G) -reimbursable cost center to the A and G-Shared cost center for the cost reporting period ending December 31, 1999.
2008D27
05-1219
17-1302
Was the Intermediary's adjustment to the provider's claimed owner's compensation proper?
2008D26
02-0326; 03-0730; 04-1130
05-0327
Whether the payment for indirect medical education (IME) and direct graduate medical education (DGME) was understand because not all managed care days and discharges for inpatient services for Medicare beneficiaries were included in the calculation.
2008D25
05-1788
05-0599
Whether the Intermediary can make an adjustment to the Provider's Medicare cost report more than three years after the original Notice of Program Reimbursement date.
2008D24
01-0679; 02-0244
05-0043
Whether the TEFRA base year used by the fiscal intermediary to compute a target amount for the Provider's excluded psychiatric unit for the February 28, 1998 and February 28, 1999 cost years was proper.
2008D23
04-1953; 05-1582
45-0076
1. Whether the Intermediary properly disallowed the Provider's request for an adjustment to the TEFRA rate-of-increase ceiling to account for the cost of new drugs that were not approved in the 1983 base year.; 2. Whether the Intermediary properly calcula...
2008D22
04-0183
31-0014
Whether the Medicare fiscal intermediary erred by not including in the calculation of the disproportionate share hospital (DSH) payment for fiscal year 2000 all of the Provider's inpatient days relating to patients who were not entitled to Medicare, but w...
2008D21
01-1910
05-6833
Whether the Intermediary properly disallowed bad debts claimed for uncollectible deductibles and coinsurance amounts related to outpatient therapy services furnished to Medicare beneficiaries dually eligible for Medicare and Medicaid, and paid under the P...
2008D20
06-0763; 06-2010
24-0213
Whether the Intermediary's refusal to reimburse the Provider for capital-related costs under the hold harmless methodology was proper.
2008D19
04-1995G
35-0002; 35-0015
Whether the Intermediary properly disallowed reimbursement for direct graduate medical education (DGME) and indirect medical education (IME) costs in the non-hospital setting by reducing the Provider's full-time equivalent (FTE) resident counts.
2008D18
01-0801
14-0174
Whether the Intermediary's adjustment disallowing the loss on disposal of depreciable assets through consolidation was proper.
2008D17
04-0088G
Various
Whether the Providers are entitled to receive additional indirect medical education (IME) and direct graduate medical education (DGME) payments for Medicare managed care enrollees for fiscal years ended December 31, 1998 and 1999.
2008D16
89-1584
45-0101
1. Whether capitalized interest that may have been amortized in future years can be expensed in the current year when future cost reports are no longer subject to reopening.; 2. Whether the Intermediary's determination of allowable interest expense which ...
2008D15
00-1182
39-0242
Whether the Intermediary's denial of the loss on disposal of assets claimed by Allentown Osteopathic Medical Center (AOMC) was proper?
2008D14
01-0215
39-5526
Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to remove Nursing Administration, Medical Records, and Social Services allocation statistics from the Provider's ancillary cost centers on the Medicare cost report were proper?
2008D13
00-1904G
Various
Whether the Intermediary's calculation of the disproportionate share hospital (DSH) payment was proper.
2008D12
04-1491; 04-1495; 04-1496
18-0080
Whether the Intermediary properly adjusted Medicare bad debts accounts considered indigent by the Provider.
2008D11
03-1549
31-0001
Whether the Medicare fiscal intermediary erred by not including all of the Provider's inpatient days relating to patients who were not entitled to Medicare, but who qualified for medical assistance under the New Jersey Charity Care Program in the calculat...
2008D10
02-0363
31-0001
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments to the Provider's direct graduate medical education and indirect medical education full-time equivalent counts were proper.
2008D09
03-0811
04-0091
Whether the Provider's Disproportionate Share Hospital (DSH) adjustment was correctly calculated.
2008D08
99-3188
45-7001
1. Whether the disallowance of $595,069 as an adjustment to administrative and general pooled costs related to a management service organization, Home Health First, was proper?; 2. Whether the disallowance of $35,390 to remove the portion of Home Health F...
2008D07
03-1056
52-0051
1. Whether the CMS improperly calculated St. Mary's Hospital's Medicare disproportionate share hospital (DSH) adjustment by excluding fifty two (52) patient days from the Supplemental Security Income (SSI) fraction.; 2. Whether the Intermediary improperly...
2008D06
99-3140
05-0369
Whether the Intermediary improperly allowed 0.54 intern and resident full time equivalent (FTE) for indirect medical education (IME) purposes on the Provider's fiscal year ended December 31. 1996 cost report.
2008D05
06-1478
31-5381
Whether the Intermediary properly adjusted Medicare bad debts.
2008D04
04-1796
22-0070
Whether the Intermediary's determination of the Provider's dental intern and resident count for purposes of calculating its direct and indirect medical education adjustment was accurate.
2008D03
01-2270; 02-1573; 03-1015
10-0032
Whether the Intermediary improperly disallowed direct graduate medical education (DGME) and indirect medical education (IME) payments with respect to discharges of Medicare beneficiaries who were enrolled in the Medicare + Choice or other Medicare risk pl...
2008D02
01-1674G
Various
1. Whether the Providers entitled to have general relief (GR) days included in the calculation of their disproportionate share percentage to the hold harmless provisions of Program Memorandum A-99-62.; 2. Whether the failure to allow the Providers to incl...
2008D01
05-0686
15-0011
Whether the recission of the hospital's approved request for Sole Community Hospital (SCH) status was proper.
2007D78
02-0328; 03-0383; 04-0283; 05-1327
05-0396
1. Whether the Intermediary improperly disallowed direct graduate medical education (DGME) and indirect medical education (IME) payments with respect to discharge of Medicare beneficiaries who were enrolled in the Medicare + Choice or other Medicare risk ...
2007D77
00-3356
44-6530
1. Did the Intermediary improperly reopen the cost report?; 2. Was the Intermediary adjustment to contract services - administrative proper?; 3-4. Were the Intermediary's adjustment to contract services - speech and occupational therapy proper?; 5. Was th...
2007D76
00-3355
42-6548
1. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to salaries proper?; 2. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to contract labor proper?; 3. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to advertising expense proper?; 4. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to utilities expense proper...
2007D75
00-3353
42-6548
1. Did the Intermediary improperly reopen the cost report?; 2. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to salaries - physical therapy proper?; 3. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to salaries - speech therapy proper?; 4. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to sal...
2007D74
00-3354
42-6548
1. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to Medicare bad debts proper?; 2-5. Were the Intermediary's adjustments to salaries - administrative, physical therapy, occupational therapy, and speech therapy - proper?; 6. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to travel...
2007D73
00-3352
42-6548
1. Did the Intermediary improperly reopen the cost report?; 2. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to Medicare bad debts proper?; 3. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to physical therapy salaries proper?; 4. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to recruiting c...
2007D72
00-3351
34-6538
1. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to bad debts proper?; 2. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to salaries proper?; 3. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to contracted labor proper?; 4. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to travel and lodging expense prope...
2007D71
00-3350
34-6538
1. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to Medicare bad debts proper? (Provider Issue 1); 2. Were the Intermediary's adjustments to salaries - administrative proper? (Provider Issue 2); 3. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to salaries - physical therapy prop...
2007D70
00-3349
34-6538
1. Did the Intermediary improperly reopen the cost report? (Provider Issue 1); 2. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to bad debts proper? (Provider Issue 2); 3. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to salaries proper? (Provider Issue 3); 4. Was the Intermedia...
2007D69
00-3348
34-6538
1. Did the Intermediary improperly reopen the cost report? (Provider Issue 1); 2. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to physical therapy salaries proper? (Provider Issue 2); 3. Was the Intermediary's adjustment to contracted occupational therapy services p...
2007D68
99-2630; 00-3142;01-1808; 02-1095; 03-1383; 01-2158
24-0063; 24-0210
1. Whether the Intermediary's exclusion of certain non-Medicaid general assistance and other state-only funded patient days (General Assistance Days or GADs) from the Provider's Medicaid Proxy was proper based on the instruction contained in Program Memor...
2007D67
03-0522G
Various
Whether the Intermediary failed to properly adjust the wage data for Rochester General Hospital used in the calculation of the Federal Fiscal Year (FFY) 2003 Wage Index for The Rochester, New York Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA).
2007D66
01-3169; 03-1194
23-5472; 23-0121
Whether the Intermediary improperly limited the Provider's hospital-based Skilled Nursing Facility's (SNF's) routine cost limit exception amount to costs in excess of 112 percent of its peer group costs rather than costs in excess of the routine cost limi...
2007D65
03-0132
44-0048
1. Whether the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) properly disallowed the Provider's request for an exception to its Skilled Nursing Facility (SNF) Routine Service Cost Limit(RCL).; 2. Whether the Provider is entitled under CMS Program Memor...
2007D64
04-0831; 04-0833
08-5034
1. Whether the Intermediary's notification of the opening of the Provider's 1996 and 1997 final settled cost reports was timely pursuant to regulatory standards.; 2. Whether the sampling methodology used by the Intermediary to disallow charges for the Pro...
2007D63
03-0721; 04-0473
23-0059
Did the Intermediary properly calculate the Provider's disproportionate share payment adjustment in accordance with Medicare regulations as set forth in 42 C.F.R. Section 412.106?
2007D62
96-2468
05-0279
Whether the Intermediary's determination of non-allowable physician office and vacant space costs was proper.
2007D61
96-1582
33-0059
Whether the Intermediary improperly limited the Provider's hospital-based Skilled Nursing Facility's (SNF's) routine cost limit exception amount to costs in excess of 112 percent of its peer group costs rather than costs in excess of the routine cost limi...
2007D60
04-1341; 04-1369
65-0001
Whether the Intermediary's adjustment disallowing the Provider's claimed withholding tax expense was proper.
2007D59
05-1792
05-0260
Whether the Intermediary properly required the use of a full year's Medicaid days in the Disproportionate Share Hospital (DSH) calculation based on its interpretation of the Benefit Improvements and Protection Act (BIPA) of 2000.
2007D58
03/0759
22-0089
Whether the Provider's Notice of Program Reimbursement (NPR) dated September 24, 2002 was an original or a revised NPR.
2007D57
00-2326
14-0088
Whether the time spent by residents conducting research in the Provider's facility as part of an approved residency program should be in the Indirect Medical Education FTE calculation.
2007D56
04-0823
35-0070
Whether the Provider is entitled to Transitional Outpatient Payments (TOPs).
2007D55
02-1565; 03-0517; 04-0338
23-0070
1. Whether the Intermediary properly determined the full-time equivalent (FTE) intern and resident count for purposes of computing the Provider's indirect medical education (IME) adjustment and the direct graduate medical education (DGME) payment for FYEs...
2007D54
00-1411
39-0128
Whether the Intermediary properly disallowed the Provider's loss on disposal of depreciable assets as a result of the merger with UPMC Braddock, a subsidiary of the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center (UPMC).
2007D53
00-1081
08-0003
Whether the Intermediary's application of the reasonable compensation equivalent (RCE) limits was proper.
2007D52
02-0530G
Various
Whether St. Luke's Hospital's letter of March 8, 2001 requesting corrections to its hospital wage data for its fiscal year ended 6/30/1999 (including documentation contained in Exhibit 1-7) satisfied the requirements established by CMS (then HCFA) set for...
2007D51
01-0883
20-0018
Was CMS' denial of the end stage renal disease (ESRD) composite rate exception correct based on applicable Medicare law? (Case 2004D26 was remanded by the US District Court)
2007D50
00-1757; 00-1859; 01-0958; 03-0180; 04-0110
44-0049
Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to the Provider's per resident amount (PRA) was proper.
2007D49
01-1010
38-0033
1. Whether the exception review process engaged in by the Health Care Financing Administration (HCFA) and the Fiscal Intermediary violated due process and fundamental fairness, including violations of the time limits established by federal regulation and ...
2007D48
05-0310
23-2029
Whether the Intermediary and CMS erred in denying the Provider's rate adjustment request made under the Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act of 1982 (TEFRA).
2007D47
05-0658
45-7789
1. Whether the Intermediary properly allocated home office cost from the finalized home office cost statement to the Provider.; 2. Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to the salaries, benefits and mileage of the program managers was proper.; 3. Whether ...
2007D46
97-1239; 97-1240
21-5279; 21-5280
Whether the Intermediary properly denied requests by Franklin Square and Good Samaritan for New Provider Exemptions from the routine cost limits for fiscal years ending 6/30/97 and 6/30/98.
2007D45
02-0162
10-5990
Whether the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) properly denied the request(s) of the Provider for an exemption from the Routine Service Cost Limits (RCLs) for the fiscal year ended December 31, 1998.
2007D44
01-2519
45-0039
Whether the Provider timely filed additional information required to entitle it to an exemption from the skilled nursing facility (SNF) routine cost limit under 42 C.F.R. section 413.30(e).
2007D43
98-1942
44-0048
Whether the Provider is entitled under CMS Program Memorandum (PM) A-99-62 to include Social Security Act, Section 1115 waiver days for the expanded Medicaid populations (a/k/a TennCare) days in the Medicaid component of the disproportionate share hospita...
2007D42
00-1882G
Various
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments disallowing the loss claimed by Medicare Providers on the disposition of assets resulting from the statutory merger of California Medicorp into Presbyterian Health Services Corporation were proper.
2007D41
04-0805
05-4135
Whether the Intermediary's decision to deny the Provider's request for an adjustment/exception to its Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act (TEFRA) target amount was proper.
2007D40
04-2269
05-0150
Whether the Provider's regular Medicare outpatient bad debts are not allowable until all collection efforts including those of a collection agency have ceased.
2007D39
04-0644
23-0230
Whether the Intermediary properly determined the full-time equivalent (FTE) intern and resident count for purposes of computing the Provider's indirect medical education adjustment (IME) and the direct graduate medical education (DGME) payment.
2007D38
00-01032; 01-2147
24-5610
Whether the denial of the Provider's request for a new provider exemption from the skilled nursing facility routine cost limits was proper.
2007D37
00-0774
53-7025
Whether the Intermediary's disallowance of accrued employee benefit costs that were not liquidated within one year after the end of the Provider's cost reporting period was proper.
2007D36
98-2095
33-7019
1. Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to related party transaction cost was proper.; 2. Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to disallow portions of membership dues expense was proper.; 3. Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to disallow certain meet...
2007D35
95-0795; 97-1098; 00-3556G; 01-2892G; 01-2936G; 01-2937G; 02-1810G; 03-1423G
Various
Whether the Intermediary improperly omitted certain inpatient hospital days from the numerator of the Medicaid low-income proxy used to calculate the Providers' disproportionate share hospital (DSH) adjustment.
2007D34
06-0456
05-0222
Whether the Intermediary improperly excluded from the Disproportionate Share Hospital (DSH) Medicaid fraction days attributable to the labor and delivery portion of stays of maternity patients who occupied licensed inpatient beds located in Labor, Deliver...
2007D33
04-2009
45-1320
Whether the Provider is eligible to receive payment on a reasonable cost basis for anesthesia services provided in its critical access hospital (CAH) by certain qualified non-physician anesthetists pursuant to 42 C.F.R. Section 412.113(c).
2007D32
00-2803
52-0174
Whether the Intermediary's determining disallow post-retirement health benefits costs for a terminated provider was proper.
2007D31
01-3521G
31-0015; 31-0051
Whether the cost report instructions improperly apply the indirect medical education (IME) full-time equivalent (FTE) cap to discharges prior to October 1, 1997.
2007D30
99-2858
17-0122
Whether the Intermediary's computation of the IME and DGME count as it relates to the following components was correct: a) Family practice rotations to the continuity care clinic; b)Internal medicine rotations to the St. Joseph campus of the Provider; c)E...
2007D29
02-0361G
Various
Whether Arizona state-funded days, such as Medically Needy/Medically Indigent (MN/MI), Eligible Low Income Children (ELIC), and/or Eligible Assistance Children (EAC) qualify as Medicaid days for purposes of determining the Provider's Medicare Disproportio...
2007D28
03-0513; 04-0456
44-0070
Whether the FYEs 6/30/00 and 6/30/01 ambulance cost per trip limits were improperly low because the Intermediary improperly applied the 5.8% outpatient operating cost reduction and the 10% outpatient capital cost reduction to base year costs utilized to c...
2007D27
04-0552
24-0001
Whether the FY 2000 ambulance cost trip limits were improperly low because the Intermediary improperly applied the 5.8% outpatient operating cost reduction and the 10% outpatient capital cost reduction to base year costs utilized to calculate those limits...
2007D26
04-1774
42-0023
1. Whether the Intermediary properly adjusted the Provider's Medicare bad debts.; 2. Whether the Intermediary properly adjusted the Provider's medical benefit plan costs.
2007D25
06-0110G; 06-0111G
67-7270: 37-7097
Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to include the Dixie Diamond Ranch as an "other" component on Schedule G of the home office cost statement was proper?
2007D24
03-1199G
Various
Whether the Intermediary should include all MediKan patient days, primary and secondary, in the Providers' disproportionate share hospital (DSH) calculation.
2007D23
01-2214
22-0060
Whether the Intermediary's denial of the application of Jordan Hospital for a new provider exemption from the routine cost limits for its provider-based skilled nursing facility was justified.
2007D22
01-0654; 02-0235
01-7009
Whether the relevant claims were timely filed by Alacare under 42 C.F.R. Section 424.44.
2007D21
03-0268; 03-0269
05-0045
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments disallowing the Provider's regular Medicare bad debts were proper.
2007D20
03-0573
36-0141
1. Did the Intermediary err in refusing to include Provider's cost for contracted perfusionist services in its wage index calculations?; 2. Did the Intermediary err in refusing to include Provider's cost for contracted pharmacy services in its wage index ...
2007D19
99-3470; 99-3471
39-0037; 39-0036
Whether the Intermediary's denial of a loss on disposition of assets due to a consolidation of Sewickley Valley Hospital and The Medical Center of Beaver was correct.
2007D18
02-2080
45-0688
Whether the Intermediary's determination of allowable Medicare bad debts based upon collection effort was proper.
2007D17
97-2936
05-0279
Whether the Intermediary improperly limited the Provider's hospital-based Skilled Nursing Facility's (SNF) routine cost limit exception amount to costs in excess of 112 percent of its peer group costs rather than costs in excess of the routine cost limit.
2007D16
03-0818
05-0578
Whether the Intermediary properly increased the number of available beds used to determine the Provider's indirect medical education (IME) payment.
2007D15
00-1836
21-7134
Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to disallow the cost of accrued compensatory time was proper.
2007D14
00-3662G; 00-3663G; 00-3664G; 02-0983G; 04-0180G; 04-0443G
Various
Whether the offshore captive investment limitations prescribed in section 2162.2.A.4 of the Provider Reimbursement Manual may properly be applied to disallow all of the premiums paid by the Providers to First Initiatives Insurance, Ltd. For the 1997-2002 ...
2007D13
97-2986
14-0119
1. Should the Provider's transplant surgery residents be included in the full-time equivalent (FTE) count for the purposes of both direct graduate medical education (DGME) and indirect medical education (IME) reimbursement?; 2. To the extent transplant su...
2007D12
03-1464
05-0308
Whether all of the Provider's outpatient total cost, total charges, and Medicare charges for separately billable End Stage Renal Disease (ESRD) drugs should be reported together on line 56 (drugs charges to patients), on line 57 (renal dialysis), or on a ...
2007D11
97-2446
05-0597
Whether the Intermediary's determination of reimbursable Medicare bad debts for beneficiaries without Medicaid eligibility (non-crossover beneficiaries) was proper.
2007D10
04-0209
13-0029
Whether the Intermediary was correct in its determination that no costs for physician assistant emergency room availability are allowable as Medicare Part A reimbursable expenses.
2007D09
01-3592G; 02-2153G; 03-0960G
Various
Whether the Intermediary properly calculated the Providers' 1996 Indirect Medical Education (IME) base year Full-Time Equivalency (FTE) cap specifically regarding residents rotating to nonhospital settings.
2007D08
05-0448
25-0085
Whether the Provider Reimbursement Review Board may grant jurisdiction for the adjustment included in the Provider's initial Notice of Program Reimbursement.; 2. Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to remove unliquidated liabilities in the year incurred...
2007D07
01-1443; 01-1444
45-0011
Whether the Intermediary's made a proper determination that Provider should be paid at the prospective payment rate for rural providers after it was certified as a provider-based entity of a hospital entitled to receive the higher urban prospective paymen...
2007D06
04-0575
17-0086
Whether the Intermediary's revised Notice of Program Reimbursement issued on July 25, 2003, that increased the Provider's Disproportionate Share Hospital (DSH) payment, included all Medicaid eligible days that would qualify for inclusion under HCFA Ruling...
2007D05
02-1833G
Various
Whether all the patient days related to patients that were eligible for medical assistance under an approved state Medicaid plan for such days were included in the Medicaid ratio of the Medicare disproportionate share hospital (DSH) payment calculation.
2007D04
99-1159; 01-2664; 02-0866
20-0024
Whether the Intermediary's denial of the Provider's request for an adjustment to its TEFRA target amount was proper.
2007D03
04-0372
33-7089
Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to reconcile the fiscal year ended (FYE) 12/31/00 home health agency aide charges to the Provider Statistical & Reimbursement Report (PS and R) was proper.
2007D02
03-0482G
31-0108; 31-0039; 31-0005
Whether it was proper for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) to include the 1999 information for Memorial Medical Center at South Amboy in the 2003 calculation of the Middlesex-Somerset-Hunterdon, New Jersey Metropolitan Statistical Area...
2007D01
97-0174
16-0024
Was the Intermediary's disallowance of the loss on disposal of assets resulting from a merger proper?
2006D58
03-0895
34-0168
Whether the Intermediary's disallowance of Medicare bad debts claimed by the Provider was justified.
2006D57
05-0051
51-5028
Whether the Intermediary properly disallowed bad debts claimed for uncollectible deductibles and coinsurance related to therapy services furnished to Medicare beneficiaries dually eligible for Medicare and Medicaid, and paid under the Part B fee schedule.
2006D56
04-0660
05-0444
Whether the Provider's regular Medicare outpatient bad debts are not allowable until all collection efforts including those of a collection agency have ceased.
2006D55
98-0580; 98-0463
14-5314
Whether the Provider's exception requests to the skilled nursing facility (SNF) routine service cost limits under 42 C.F.R. Section 413.30(f) was properly denied because the Provider did not request the exceptions within 180 days of the original notices o...
2006D54
02-1420
10-0122
Whether the Intermediary's adjustment of disproportionate share hospital (DSH) reimbursement based on its determination that the Provider had less than 100 available beds for DSH eligibility purposes was proper.
2006D53
96-0480
26-0104
Whether the Intermediary's adjustment that disallowed the consolidation of all of the Provider's therapy services into a single cost center was proper.
2006D52
04-0565
50-1304
1. Whether the Intermediary's adjustment to direct nursing costs was proper.; 2. Whether the Intermediary's adjustment increasing the total patient days to include respite care days was proper.
2006D51
02-1212
52-0087
Whether the denial of the Provider's End Stage Renal Disease (ESRD) exception request was in compliance with 42 C.F.R. section 413.180(h), which states: "(h) Approval of an exception request. An exception request is deemed approved unless it is disapprove...
2006D50
01-1326G
07-5234; 07-5210; 07-5198
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments to disallow rental expense as a cost incurred with a related organization were proper.
2006D49
96-2013G
07-5234; 07-5210
Whether the Intermediary's adjustments to disallow rental expense as a cost incurred with a related organization were proper.
2006D48
98-2103; 99-1746; 00-2563; 03-0127; 03-048